2002-O-16
ORDINANCE NO. 2002-0-16
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
EDGEWATER, FLORIDA; REPEALING SIX (6) LOCAL
AMENDMENTS TO THE FLORIDA BUILDING CODE
ENACTED BY ORDINANCE #2002-0-03; REPEALING
SECTIONS 210-52(b )(1), 230-70(a), 310-16, 336-4(2), 339-3(a)(1)
and 680-20 RELATING TO THE NATIONAL FIRE
PROTECTION ASSOCIATION (NFPA) 70-NATIONAL
ELECTRICAL CODE; RESTATING SECTIONS 230-50, 680-8
AND 680-11; PROVIDING FOR NOTICE TO THE FLORIDA
BUILDING COMMISSION AND THE UNIFIED CODE
COMMITTEE; PROVIDING FOR CODIFICATION,
CONFLICTING PROVISION, SEVERABILITY AND
APPLICABILITY; ESTABLISHING AN EFFECTIVE DATE
AND FOR ADOPTION.
WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Edgewater, Florida, has made the following
determinations:
1. On February 11,2002, City Council adopted Ordinance #2002-0-03 which adopted
the Florida Building Code together with nine (9) local amendments to Chapter 1 (Administration)
and to the National Fire Protection Association (NFP A) 70 - National Electrical Code (NEC);and
2. The local amendments adopted by the Cities of Edgewater, Daytona Beach, Port
Orange, Ormond Beach, and South Daytona (collectively, the "Respondents") were challenged by
the Florida Home Builders Association, Inc., the V olusia Home Builders Association, Inc., Stan
Shirah and Florida Pool and Spa Association, Inc., (collectively, the "Petitioners"); and
3. Petitioners and Respondents subsequently entered into a Stipulation and Settlement
Agreement whereby six (6) of the nine (9) local amendments adopted by Ordinance #2002-0-03
would be repealed and the Petitioners agreed to take no further action to challenge the other three
(3) local amendments, leaving those three (3) still active.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ENACTED by the City Council of the City of Edgewater,
Florida as follows:
St! UGk till ongh passages are deleted.
Underlined passages are added.
2002-0-16
1
PART A.
PART B.
PART C.
-.".-
LOCAL AMENDMENTS RELATING TO TPtt NATIONAL FIRE
PROTECTION ASSOCIATION (NFPA) 70 - NATIONAL
ELECTRICAL CODE (NEC), FURTHER DESCRIBED AS SECTIONS
210-52(b)(1), 230-70(a), 310-16, 336-4(2), 339-3(a)(1) and 680-20 ARE
HEREBY REPEALED.
LOCAL AMENDMENTS RELATING TO THE NATIONAL FIRE
PROTECTION ASSOCIATION (NFPA) 70 - NATIONAL
ELECTRICAL CODE (NEC), FURTHER DESCRIBED AS SECTIONS
230-50, 680-8 and 680-11 ARE HEREBY REST A TED.
NOTICE TO THE FLORIDA BUILDING COMMISSION.
In accordance with Section 533.73(4)(a), Florida Statutes, the City Clerk shall transmit a
certified copy of this Ordinance to the Florida Building Commission within thirty (30) days of
enactment along with forwarding an additional copy by electronic means.
PART D.
NOTICE TO THE UNIFIED CODE COMMITTEE AND VOLUSIA
COUNCIL OF GOVERNMENT.
The City Clerk is hereby directed to transmit a certified copy ofthis Ordinance together with
a copy of the Stipulation and Settlement Agreement to the Unified Code Committee and Volusia
Council of Government.
PART E.
CODIFICATION.
Provision of this ordinance shall be incorporated in the Code of Ordinances of the City of
Edgewater, Florida, and the word "ordinance", may be changed to "section", "article", or other
appropriate word, and the sections ofthis ordinance may be renumbered or relettered to accomplish
such intention; provided, however, that Parts C through I shall not be codified.
PART F.
CONFLICTING PROVISIONS.
All conflicting ordinances and resolutions, or parts thereof in conflict with this ordinance,
are hereby superseded by this ordinance to the extent of such conflict.
Shtick Huongh passages are deleted.
Underlined passages are added.
2002-0-16
2
......
.....,
PART G.
SEVERABILITY AND APPLICABILITY.
If any portion of this ordinance is for any reason held or declared to be unconstitutional,
inoperative, or void, such holding shall not effect the remaining portions of this ordinance. If this
ordinance or any provisions thereof shall be held to be inapplicable to any persons, property, or
circumstances, such holding shall not affect its applicability to any other person, property, or
circumstance.
PART H.
EFFECTIVE DATE.
This Ordinance shall become effective immediately upon passage and adoption.
P ART I.
ADOPTION.
After Motion by Councilwoman Rhodes and Second by Councilman Brown, the vote on the
first reading of this ordinance held on October 7, 2002, was as follows:
AYE NAY
Mayor Donald A. Schmidt X -
Councilman James P. Brown X
Councilman Myron F. Hammond X
Councilwoman Harriet E. Rhodes X -
Councilwoman Judy Lichter X
StlOGk tl.rough passages are deleted.
Underlined passages are added.
3
2002-0-16
After Motion by Counciii.an Hammond and Second by Coalman Brown
the vote on the second reading of this ordinance was as follows:
AYE NAY
Mayor Donald A. Schmidt Absent
Councilman James P. Brown x
Councilman Myron F. Hammond x
Councilwoman Harriet E. Rhodes x
Councilwoman Judy Lichter x
PASSED AND DULY ADOPTED this 21' day of October, 2002.
ATTEST:
I!,
Susan J. �'4�udsicmlh
('ih ('Icrk
For the use and reliance only by the City of
Edgewater, Florida. Approved as to form and
legality by: Scott A. Cookson, Esquire
City Attorney
Foley & Lardner
St ack dnough passages are deleted.
Underlined passages are added.
2oo2-at6
V.
CITY COUNCIL OF THE
CITY O/F�EDGEWyA,TTER, FLORIDA
By:- N/AOd� Q 2"'b'f
Mayor -vice Harriet Rhodes
C���n7' tirrh
Robin L. Matusick 1`
Legal Assistant
Approved by the City Council of the City of
Edgewater at a meeting held on this I
day of October 2002 under
Agenda Item No. 6-a
::>c.r
j.J ",..c J.~:..co
rI'\:UIWI: rUL!:;, I 0; 1,...":.KUi~C.r<.
AU' U."UL' '"'l..:)
Jugn"tNlX
Page HHZ
'-"
AUG-)S-82 iSles FROM,FOLEY & LAROMER
IO:48764~4;J
I"'PlC;;~ 2/S
BEFORE TIm VOLUSIAlFLAGLEK COUNfIES
CODE COMPLIANCE REVIEW BOARD
mE FLORIDA HOME BUILl)ERS)
ASSOCIATION,. INC_,. THE )
VOLUSIA HOME BUlLDERS. )
lNC-. and STAN SHIRAH. and )
FLORIDA POOL AND SPA )
ASSOClA TION, INC-3 )
)
Petitionm, )
)
vs. )
)
THE ClTY OF DAYTONA )
BEACH. FLOlUDA. THE CITY OF)
EDGEW ATER, fLORIDA. THE )
CITY OF ORAt~QE CITY. )
FLORIDA. DIE arY OF )
ORMOND BEAca FLORlD~ )
THE CITY OF PORT ORANGE, )
FLORIDA.. and mE CITY OF )
SOUI'H DAYfO~ FLORIDA, )
)
Respondents. )
)
~U1tAnON AND SETTlf1t~ A.gu:~l\1ENT
WHEREAS the Respondents have aUopted local ameodmcnts to th~ Florida Building
Code; ~
'WliatEAS Petitioners are involved in the constnJction tx'ades in the Respondent
municipalities and ~ governed by. and a:ffected by, the local ameD<lments to the building ~
adopted by the ~DCknt$; and,
WHEREAS Petitioners ba~ chaJleogcd the local amendments as adopted by the
R~enQl ~ the VolusialPlagler Countic:i Code CompIiaDCe Revi~ Board pursuant to
the prc~isiolls of Section 553-73,. Fkmda SlalUles; and,.
WHEREAS the \l'I1d.c:r$ignecl attorneys ~ the Respondalt municipalities 8D"cc
th~ Witb the exception of the local am~rlwents related to Sections 230.50~ 68~ and 680-11.
the local amendmmts adopted by the ~ndc:nt mwncipalilies do not meet the statutory
Y1M~_1
~ wt9Clt*:lj;4_
- -
~ar~UL(~~ ~l9htfax
Pa.ge 88J
AUO-19-fJ2 16.85 FRQJ\OI.EY & LARDNER
IO,q,.,76QS17Q3
l"'ACE
3rs
mteria for local amcodments to lhe Florida BwlcJing Code as contained in Section 553.73.
F/(JrUf4 Statrltes; ~
WHlmEAS ~ final hecing on Petitio~' challenge to the local mnendmclltS is
scheduled to be beam by the VQ1usia/f]agler COUUti~ Code Compliance Review Board 011
Augus[ 20. 2002: and,
W'HEREAs the parties signing below believe that the p~osed sdUernenl of this
proceeding as 5tated below is fair cd equitable and is couistQl with the provisions and intent
. .
or the Florida Statutes goveming rite building code; ~
WHEREAS all parties hentQ acknowledge that this StipulatiOlI and Settlement
AgreeJ:nem can only be imp1euJ.ented by official action of the Respoud.ent mUnicipalities and that
the uodcrsigned attorneys. for the R.e$pondem municipalities do not hav~ the authority 10 bind
~ juri$dictions;
BE rr ~ORE AGREED:
I. Each of the \1Ddetsigm:d artorneys for the Respondeat muuicipalitie:; I8J:ees to
present this Stipulation and Settlement &greemeut to his or hc:r ~ve govemiDg commissiOn
within 30 da.ys of the:: exeeution of this agteemeot,. If the governing Commission ac;ccpts the terms
and conditions contained herein. they $hall adopt an ortIifUtJCe repealing the local amendlnents to
SectioDS 210-S2(bXI), 230-70(a1310-16, 336-4(2), 339...3(a)(1) and 680-20 and any other local
technical 8DleD4menr to tho Aorida BuiJdiD,g Code DOt li~ in Paragraph ~ below, within. 60
days of the execvtion of this aueement.
2. The Petition~ agree not to rake ~y further attioll tQ dWIenge the lOCal
amen&ncnts to the Florida Bui1irIXlg CO<!e rvbded to Se<;tiotuJ 230.50> 68Q-S au(! 680-1 t upon !he
repeal oflbose loea1 aten<lments listed in Paragraph 1~ abov~ In the event that any Respondeut
mUIJ..icipality does J1CJt Ipprove this Stipulation a;ld Sett:l~ A~c:m and. does DOt repeal
those kx:a1 amcnclme:nts listed in Pmagrapb 1~ above. PetitiO!1QS nlily challenge all of the local
amendmCDts in that municipality. By ~eting Uno Ibis Stipulation <U1d Settte:coem Asr~
Petitioners are not agr.eiug that att)' of the local amendments meet the criteria {or local
amend~ to the Florida Building Code.
3. The Respondent IDI1nicipafuiC$ agree that, upon ~ce of this Stipulation and
Settletuent ~ aDd repeal of those Ioea1 amen4ments list<:d in p~ 1. above. they
$ha.U notify the Unified ~ Committee and shall Teq1lesl that the UlIifonn Code Committee
"'"~.1
~""'~Ml
::J.r.r
~KUM'~ULeY & L~~UNeK
..3 "''''' 'VJ,:'<:::S
&U'U;;;~f~; - -n-lgnU-aX
Page 8EM
.. ..O"'POs.ay':~ EDGEWAT~~.4.?.=".:J
104 N. RIVERSIDE DRIVE
POBox 100 - Edgewater. Flc:rida 32132-0100
. ~=-3245 SunCom 371-7005
with fbiI ~ ..at Scttl__ ~~ that ~se
... -mqtdm.4ta listed in hrqnph I. aboft, 1M r=peaJed in t!w bIpondeat
~- - ... - ~ ill aD ... jvdt6lfou CGIb~" Ute Unified Code
.aca
4.....
~~aiucc.
4_ The p8Itie. ... to ftlqIaM dIM dMr V~ CcNatiw c;va Complienc.
~ BaIrd pIIce 1be abcmHtyJed __ ill ~ ... . period of 60 .,. 10 .now t!Ht
l+llJ~WiYCI of lie R~ ~ to po.... tIdt ~ _ Scttllftlenl
,
~ to .. pv.... GO~"'rlliGa ... eo ... ill ~V'fIl.. impl-.awiall Al..
IUd of60 cta)'l. PtdIioDa lid ~ ...~~ Ie'-'loc:al ""'m-'~ to it. P!Drida
~ CWeI-.s. iJJ ~4pb ~ ~ ___ j1IritdiGtiflll btbaw ~f~ 1IIOIe Ioca1
~1l- JiICId m P-.mph 1, .... If.,. ,i.4~" JIDt ....~ dIG ~JNion
.. ~-- ~ wllUu . ..,. of ita .__.t_ w .. . .... lIMe lGclal
~CI BIh4 ill P...-,h 1, Ilxno. __ thIl1:lmD ~ PMIJi....... may ~.....
GbIU..... io tIh~a~~ ..,..u aftB lDCI1,.~.. ..J.~ by 1bM~~ 11I4
daiJ Sd,u~ ID4 ~ AIre-"'( t!aID be of DO ... OP 4IftilIat ... IWflIlCd to 1hM
jW'iIldl" d.DIL
s. l1U IIipuIati04 - ,..... AtP.IW~. ....... DO ~ or em. IIDIil
"""_4l1ytl-. tIJII~ .......ve., of... or..,............
IN.WD'NISS WRD.BoP w:a S5T CMI. HANDS GIiI1t* _or ....... 2G02..
POa PJ!I'lII\RGJl PI mtJDA JIOOI.,
AND SPA AISOCIATtON. !Me.:
P01t PE1'lJ1ONI5aS pr 0lt'UlA HOIG
1IUItJ:J8IUI AUOCIATJON. INC.,
VOUJlIABcta BtJlI.DI!U
~T1ON, JNe...IIIIlSTAN
SIIDtAB:
~
. . -~-
PMlR.. DaAIy. ~~
~~=~-
AOC-J9-02 1~,5? FROM )8 AOMJNISTRA~ION
FOR RESPONlJENT CITY OF
ORANGE crrv. FLORIDA:
Wllliam ~Blquitc
FORRBSPONDENT ClTY OF
PORTO~ FLOR11>A:
Mal"prat Robart6, I!equirv
tvn-.a"-'lIl'.l
~ ""M2-=M~
4&J.-a.u'1l;;;I,1IlO::J.& '-"w
~U'U~UL"~ ~Jgn~rdX
10. 9(,)4 $-4? :.1008
POR RBSPONDBNT CITY OJ.'
lIDGRW A1'BR,. FLORIDA:
Scott 'CooJc1oa. ~
PORRESPONnEN"f CiTY OF
ORMOND BBAClI. FWRlDA:
SalIdra Up~l1I'Cb, F4CJlIi.-e
FORRESPONDBNT CITY OP
SOUTH DAYTONA.. FLOku)A:
Scott S~ EiQuif"a
rMu!:.
Puge 885;
~/l:
PACE S
(
10,30 FROM,FOLEY & L~RDNER
SEP-13-02
. 'AU~-19-2002 MON 03: 32 PM ~Ofi, Me I NTOSH, COLBE
FOlt RESPONDENT CITY OF
DAYTONA BEACH, FLORrDA:
Anthony Jacks~n. Esquire
FOR RF..sPONl>ENT CITY OF
ORANGE CITY~ FLO:RIOA:
__W:L
William Rei$chmann, Esquire
FOR RESPONDENT C1TY Of
PORT ORANGE, FLORIDA:
Jay ^da1l1s~ Esquire
a~' U :.:....-.~.; - n ignuax
.
FAX KO. 407't1tO 2379
FOR RESPONDENT CITY OF
EDGEWATER. FLORIDA:
Score Cookson. Esquire
FOR. RESPONDENT CUi' OF
ORMOND BEACH, FLORlDk
Jay Adams. Esquire
FOR RESPONDENT CITY OF
SOUTH DAYTONA FLORIDA:
Soott SimPSOfl. Esquire
Page BHG
P. 02/02
AUC-19-&2 16~0S FRO~ JLEV ~ LARDNE~
FOR RESPONDENT ClTY OF
DAYTONA BEACH, FLORIDA:
Anthony Jackson. ~uire
FOR RESPONDENT CflY OF
ORANGE CIlY~ FLORIDA:
William Reisebmamz" Esquire
FOR RESPONDENT CITY OF
PORT ORANGE, FLORIDA;
~
Jay . .
~-,
~""'~-~
&~'U4U~'~J nlgn~tdx
P.we B8~
IP;41liJ1Ei'iEl1743
PAGE s/s
FOR RESPONDENt CITY OF
EOGEWATER. FLORIDA:
FOR RESPOWENT CITY OF
ORMOND BEAca FLORIDA:
~Od--\
1 . Esquire
FOR RESPONDENT CITY OF
SOUTH DAYTONA. FLORIDA:
Scott Simpson~ Esquire
. OS!i~/2aa2 13:48
25S973?
FOR RESPoNDENT CITY OF
DA YTONA BEACH, lLORlDA:
Anthony Jackson. &quite
FOR RBSPONDSNT CITY OF
ORANGE CITY. FLORIDA:
Williun ~bmarf&quir~
(
FOR RESPONDENT crzy OF
PORT ORANGE, FLORIDA.:
MBtDt'Gt Ro~. &quire
'rUt'~.1
~~""IW
-- - &~... '-"A U.A.
Pdge B8B
COaLE .eM) SlJoFSQ
P4(,E 05
FOR REsPONDBNT CITY OF
lIDGaw A TEk. FLoRIDA:
Scott Coolcaon. Esquire
FOR RESPONDHNT CITY OF
OlU\{OND BEA~ FLORlDA:
. Sandra UpcbUJCb,. :&quire
FOR REsPC1NDBNT CITY OF
soum DAYTON~ FLORIDA;
&~./~
USiInpson, .