03-17-2003 - Regular
W'
....,
.r
CITY COUNCIL OF EDGEWATER
REGULAR MEETING
MARCH 17, 2003
7:00 P.M.
COMMUNITY CENTER
MINUTES
CALL TO ORDER
Mayor Schmidt called the Regular Meeting to order at 7:07 p.m. in
the Community Center.
ROLL CALL
Mayor Donald Schmidt
Councilman James Brown
Councilman Myron Hammond
Councilwoman Harriet Rhodes
Councilwoman Judith Lichter
City Manager Kenneth Hooper
City Clerk Susan Wadsworth
Paralegal Robin Matusick
Present
Present
Present
Present
Present
Present
Present
Present
INVOCATION, PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
There was a silent invocation and pledge of allegiance to the
Flag.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
There were no minutes to be approved at this time.
PRESENTATIONS/PROCLAMATIONS/PLAQUES/CERTIFICATES/DONATIONS
A. Recognition of appointed/reappointed Board/Committee members
There were no Board or Committee members to be recognized.
B. Meet and Welcome Volusia County Councilwoman Patricia Northey
Mayor Schmidt introduced and welcomed Volusia County Councilwoman
Patricia Northey. Councilwoman Northey thanked the Mayor and
Council saying it was a pleasure to be here and gave a brief
Page - 1 -
City Council Regular Meeting
March 17, 2003
'-"
...."
background of her time as a Councilwoman. She discussed the
progress of S.R. 442 as well as the turnpike study. Councilwoman
Northey explained turnpike extensions between the Seminole County
area to Edgewater/New Smyrna along Interstate 95 is not going to
happen. The funding is not available. She also stated the ECHO
Grant will be before the County Council for approval on
March 27th, 2003. Councilwoman Northey said she sees no reason
the grant won't be accepted. She said she is pleased that
Edgewater applied for the grant and the funding is going to be
there. Also discussed was an update on trails being worked on.
Currently in process is a trail covering the southern part of the
County that will link with Brevard County. The trail starts in
the Enterprise area and will run to Brevard following the May town
route. Councilwoman Northey brought a copy of the County Council
goals for Council to review. She explained an important goal
this year is Smart Growth. The need for the County to grow
smarter and continue to maintain a high quality of life. She said
this along with economic development would be the main focus for
the County this year.
C. John Massey, Massey Enterprises, presenting plaque to Law
Enforcement Officer of the Quarter, Kim Rash.
Police Chief, Mike Ignasiak, announced Officer Kim Rash as the
Officer of the Quarter for the Edgewater Police Department.
Officer Rash and the sponsor for the Officer of the Month, John
Massey of Massey Enterprises were asked to come forward. The
Police Chief said Officer Rash is being recognized for
outstanding efforts in solving numerous thefts to Riverside Drive
residence. Using her knowledge from previous local crime
problems, Officer Rash was quickly able to identify a primary
subject. She was able to recover a large number of stolen items,
such as boats, boat motors, marine equipment and personal
property of several New Smyrna Beach and Edgewater residences.
Officer Rash also sits on the local mentoring board for Indian
River and Edgewater Elementary Schools and is a mentor herself.
She was able to procure $1,500.00 in grants to support the
mentoring program. For those actions she is being named Officer
of the Quarter.
John Massey thanked the Edgewater Police for their good work and
rapid responses.
D. Mayor proclaiming the week of May 18 through May 24, 2003 as
"National Public Works Week."
Page - 2 -
City Council Regular Meeting
March 17, 2003
'-"
....,
Mayor Schmidt read the proclamation from the office of the Mayor.
E. Bike Week Report by Captain Jill Danigel
Captain Danigel reported on the experiences of Bike Week. She
first gave the prospective of Code Enforcement as well as the
Police Departments. From February 28th through March 9th the
special activities permits issued for the ten days were to No
Name Saloon, Earthquake Magoons and Edgewater Methodist Church
for March 7~ and 8~' Captain Danigel explained there were only
two complaints on the outdoor music and the owners of No Name
Saloon complied with lowering the noise monitor readings. She
said a good working relationship was had with the establishments
and no problems were experienced.
Captain Danigel explained manpower personnel costs. The hours of
the Code Enforcement Officers were flexed to minimize the costs;
ending with twenty hours of overtime and three hours of
compensatory time for a total of $500.28.
Captain Danigel said she was able to obtain statistics from
Police Chief Mike Ignasiak for their activities during Bike Week.
A total of 477 traffic citations were issued and eight arrests
made. The Police Department had 84 hours of compensatory time for
the motor patrol and 10 hours of overtime paid for by R&R Groves
who had a special activity permit and No Name Saloon paid for
twenty-six hours of overtime.
Captain Danigel completed her report commenting, the overall
experience went well, stating it was beneficial having Code
Enforcement Officers covering the entire duration of the each
special activity.
Councilwoman Rhodes questioned the $500.28 spent for overtime for
Code Enforcement being paid for by the taxpayers. She said that
needs to be fixed. City Manager Hooper said the purpose of the
report is to show the costs encountered. He stating there is
income from traffic citations as well as other areas. He
suggested examining the costs and possibly in the future the fees
for special activity permits could be altered or an adjustment
for the inspections for special activity permits requiring a
larger number of visits. He said we are looking for a balance.
The dispersment of revenue from citations was discussed. The City
Page - 3 -
City Council Regular Meeting
March 17,2003
'-'
.."
Manager said a portion of the citation monies goes to the City.
City Manager Hooper also commented on the communication between
staff during the special events, saying it was the best working
relationship he has encountered from Fire/Rescue and the Police
Department working together.
Councilwoman Lichter remarked this is the first year she did not
receive phone calls of complaint during bike week.
CITIZEN COMMENTS
Jay Michael McKay, 1717 S. Riverside Drive, brought to the
Council's attention an occurrence on Riverside Drive. He had
contacted Terry Wadsworth, Director of Environmental Services
regarding a drainage problem (flooding) that existed on Parkwood
and Riverside Drives for several years. Without getting into
specifics Mr. McKay said Mr. Wadsworth and his staff were able to
correct the problem in a timely manner. Mr. McKay commended the
staff of Public Works (Environmental Services) for doing an
outstanding job.
Mr. McKay also stated he had a problem that the Police Department
was able to handle efficiently, indicating that the officer was
definitely on top of his game. He said he has seen a positive
change in the Police Department.
Mr. McKay made reference to a workshop he attended on March 3rd
pertaining to two story dwellings as well as other issues. He
stressed concern over the negative comments regarding setback
issues to various lots on Riverside Drive and commended the
Planning and Zoning Board for listening to the people and
checking for all compliances before building. He said he hopes
the City Council will be careful and not impede the growth but
rather encourage it. Mr. McKay also provided a letter to the
City Clerk from a neighbor unable to attend the meeting.
Pat Card, 3019 Willow Oak Drive, thanked the Council for hearing
his views. He expressed apprehension over people being able to
enjoy the views along Riverside Drive. He is worried that people
will not be allowed to build along Riverside consistent with the
standards of the neighborhood. He feels a change to the code
eliminating the building of homes on the east side of Riverside
Drive will be to the benefit of a very few, and a detriment to
all of Edgewater because of its impact.
Page - 4 -
City Council Regular Meeting
March 17, 2003
...,
.....,
Mike Visconti, 316 Pine Breeze Drive, thanked the Council, the
Mayor, City Manager and Chief Barlow for the phone calls and
cards he received during his recent illness. He listed numerous
projects that are in progress or have been completed in the City.
He thinks Edgewater is doing a marvelous job drawing people to
Edgewater.
Mr. Visconti questioned whether there was an ordinance in place
for ParkTowne Industrial Center that involves landscaping and
beatification? Councilwoman Lichter explained an industrial
association similar to a homeowners association is in place so as
to maintain a quality park.
Mr. Visconti also inquired whether the application forms for "The
All American City" had been filled out. City Manager Hooper
replied this wasn't being done this year as staff will pursue
those grants that bring money back first. However, next year
staff will probably look at "The All American City".
Ferd Heeb, 115 N. Riverside Drive, made reference to a discussion
he had after the March 3rd workshop when he pointed out issues
relative to setbacks on riverfront property and the lack of
ecological and environmental impact caused by the proximity of a
structure to the water. Mr. Heeb addressed some of the economic
issues limiting the development or redevelopment of Riverside
Drive property. He gave an example of a potential businessman
wanting to develop a 40,000 sq. ft. manufacturing plant in
ParkTowne Industrial Center and also planning to build/rebuild a
family home on Riverside Drive. Taxes resulting in this project
would be approximately half of what he would be paying on his
plant. Mr. Heeb stated the major asset in drawing businesses to
this area is the life style. Many of the entrepreneurs we want
moving to this area are going to want to live on Riverside Drive.
He feels by limiting the development/redevelopment of these
properties will be a detriment to the City.
CITY COUNCIL REPORTS
Councilwoman Lichter related her experiences while attending two
Little League openings. She also talked about the Water
Transition Group of which she is a City representative. She
stated having City Manager Hooper on the finance committee and
ideas from Terry Wadsworth, Director of Environmental Services
that the east side west side doesn't have to be treated alike
when the new entity is formed. She said by the year 2010 we are
Page - 5 -
City Council Regular Meeting
March 17, 2003
.....
"""'"
going to have a shortage of potable water. She said the
differences between the east side and west side is being overcome
and everyone is working together.
Councilwoman Lichter questioned Mr. Wadsworth regarding the
acceptance of tree cuttings and similar debris at the Mango Tree
facility. Mr. Wadsworth said the practice of accepting such
things has stopped. There were various problems that resulted
from disposing debris at the facility.
Councilwoman Lichter said on behalf of the homeowners wishing to
use the service, perhaps there could be an identification process
created for the residents so the service could be resumed. Mr.
Wadsworth said residents presently are able to bag or put piles
at the roadside to be picked up by the City. Councilwoman
Lichter said when the city increased the price for trash removal
it was said there wouldn't be any changes in service and she
considered the closing of the Mango Tree facility a down grading
change. She said she would appreciate this being looked into.
Mayor Schmidt said his recent trip to Tallahassee with the Vice-
Mayor and the City Manager for Volusia Day was very eventful. He
said he felt they had the best day they've had in three or four
years. An issue covered at the meeting was health care and the
speed limits on U.S. Highway 1. The City Manager said the City
has received notification that D.O.T. has been contacted
regarding the speed limits. The evacuation on Rt. 442 was
discussed and the whole realm of how Rt. 442 affects the City.
Also discussed were annexations and how to eliminate some of the
"pockets" that a lot of the Cities have. Mayor Schmidt said they
were able to meet with everybody they wanted to see.
Councilman Brown had nothing at this time.
Councilwoman Rhodes, wished to publicly thank City Clerk Susan
Wadsworth for her efforts in making the appointments for Volusia
Day, saying her help made the day more constructive.
Councilman Hammond thanked the Police and Fire/Rescue Departments
for their hard work during Bike Week.
PUBLIC HEARINGS, ORDINANCES AND RESOLUTIONS
A. 2nd Reading, Ord. No. 2003-0-01, Glenn Storch, authorized
agent for Hacienda Development Corp., requesting annexation of
Page - 6 -
City Council Regular Meeting
March 17, 2003
'-'
....."
approximately 18.27 acres of land located east of US 1 and west
of Hacienda del Rio and authorization for the Mayor to execute
the associated Annexation Agreement
City Manager Hooper asked Paralegal, Robin Matusick to read the
ordinance into the record. City Manager Hooper said this is the
second reading to annex 18.27 acres of commercial property in
front of Hacienda del Rio into the City. He said this is
important to the City, in making the City contiguous with the
marina (at Planning and Zoning level for annexation). City
Manager Hooper recommended approval.
There being no comments from the public Mayor Schmidt closed the
public hearing.
Councilwoman Lichter moved to accept Ordinance No. 2003-0-01,
seconded by Councilman Brown. The motion CARRIED 5-0.
B. 2nd Reading, Ord. No. 2003-0-02, George Scott, President of
Edgewater Terrace Inc., requesting rezoning of property located
east of Coco Palm Drive, south of Pine Avenue and west of US 1
from R-4 (Multi-Family Residential) to RPUD (Residential Planned
Unit Development) and approval of the associated Zoning Agreement
City Manager Hooper said the next item "C" is related to this
ordinance. Both items "6-B" and "6-C" will be discussed. He then
asked Paralegal, Robin Matusick to read the ordinance into the
record. City Manager Hooper explained the first part is a zoning
agreement. This is a standard zoning agreement for a RPUD
(Residential Planned Unit Development) containing lot sizes of
(75'x 115'). All the setback requirements are defined and the
request is for 75 single-family lots or 2.99 units per acre,
which is below the maximum for that land use district. The
Planning and Zoning Board have recommended approval; the
attorneys and staff have reviewed and approved Ordinance No.
2003-0-02.
Councilwoman Lichter questioned the present zoning district of R-
4, Single-family residential that appeared in the Councils
packets. City Manager Hooper explained that R-4 is a multi-family
and/or duplex use that is being changed to RPUD, Single-family.
To answer additional questions City Manager Hooper explained the
benefits of changing the zoning to RPUD, which included the
benefits of having a homeowners association that is required in a
RPUD.
Page - 7 -
City Council Regular Meeting
March 17, 2003
--.
....,
Councilwoman Lichter also inquired whether a nursing home was
still proposed in the same area. Chief Planner, Darren Lear
replied there have been no applications at this time.
Mayor Schmidt asked for comments from the public. Mr. Hal
Armstrong of Azalea Drive expressed concern with the traffic
passing on Coco Palm. He also asked if the subject property
would have access from U.S. 1 or Coco Palm Dr. Coucilwoman
Rhodes replied that Coco Palm and Falcon Drives would provide
access. Mr. Armstrong also expressed his dissatisfaction with the
drainage ditch and the amount of traffic that will be generated.
Mr. Armstrong stated there is a need for a three way stop sign
at Coco Palm and Azalea Drive.
Councilwoman Rhodes asked Mr. Hooper if a three way stop sign was
a possibility. City Manager Hooper replied it is a possibility,
however, it is a different matter that may be looked into to
determine traffic volumes and other relevant issues. He stated
this would be addressed. Discussion ensued regarding traffic and
the endangerment to children that could be encountered when
building a subdivision. Councilwoman Lichter interjected that
changing the zoning to single-family residential will reduce the
traffic congestion. In addition Councilwoman Lichter agreed that
traffic surveys were necessary.
Councilwoman Rhodes asked Mr. Wadsworth if he was aware of
drainage problems? Mr. Wadsworth responded that drainage
problems were created by the Rt. 442 project involving the
extension of water lines. There is also edge of the pavement
failure on the east side of Coco Palm Dr. through from 20th
Street to the Boulevard. The contractors are aware of the
problems and they will be rectified. Mr. Wadsworth said when the
442 project is completed there will be no west turn off Coco Palm
Drive onto Rt. 442, this should reduce some of the traffic.
Robert Fuller of 408 Sea Hawk Court requested a reconsideration
of the decision for Falcon Avenue as a main entrance to Mariners
Gate. He asked if there had been traffic studies done. City
Manager Hooper replied that the developers are preparing a
traffic report. During the final engineering portion of the
project these reports are taken into consideration as far as the
design and the connection to Falcon Avenue. He also said the
Police Chief is looking into vehicles turning, speeding, running
stop signs etc. Mr. Hooper also explained for Mr. Fuller that
Page - 8 -
City Council Regular Meeting
March 17, 2003
'-'
....,
the traffic study is done in phases. He explained tonight's
request is the first step in the process (rezoning and a
preliminary plat approval). Then the final design plan will be
submitted. During the final submittal the final traffic study
will be incorporated into the final design plans. He said the
numbers have been presented and it shows it works from a traffic
point of view. Further discussion followed regarding the
submittal process for rezoning and preliminary plat approval.
Mr. Austin Moore, 813 Egret Court, stated he has no objection to
the rezoning. However, he expressed concern over the traffic that
will be generated from over 255 houses in Pelican Cove West as
well as the traffic from the bank. Mr. Moore suggested the
Council go to the corner of U.S.1 and Falcon Avenue to understand
how poor the traffic conditions are. He also commented that the
south side of the plot shows a retention area 958 feet long by 75
feet long and asked if there is a need for something so big. He
suggested that the Council consider making this area a low cost
park, as the variety of birds/animals is so plentiful. City
Manager Hooper said this would not be possible because of the
need for the retention pond.
Councilwoman Lichter suggested that some research be done on the
left turn lane from the bank onto Falcon Avenue. City Manager
Hooper agreed to look into this traffic problem.
Elizabeth Bower, 2139 South Riverside Drive, stated there should
be a method of "birth control" for building additional homes.
She also said the congestion in the Falcon Avenue area is already
congested and the addition of 75 homes will make matters worse.
Chairman Schmidt said being there are no additional comments
closed the public hearing.
Councilwoman Rhodes said she has several concerns regarding the
request and said she needed more time to personally investigate
the Falcon Avenue area.
Councilwoman Rhodes moved to have the request tabled until the
first meeting in May. There being no second the motion FAILED.
Councilwoman Lichter moved to accept Ordinance No. 2003-0-02,
seconded by Councilman Brown. The motion CARRIED 4-1 with
Councilwoman Rhodes voting no.
Page - 9 -
City Council Regular Meeting
March 17, 2003
liIW'
....,
C. Public Hearing, George Scott, President of Edgewater Terrace,
Inc. requesting preliminary plat approval for property located
east of Coco Palm Drive, south of Pine Avenue and west of US 1
for a 75-1ot single-family residential subdivision to be known as
Mariners Gate
City Manager Hooper said the packet provided is a preliminary
plat for 75 lots, (25.12 acres) indicating lot dimensions. He
said the only modification is the Falcon Avenue connection will
be converted into a "T" intersection. The plat has been reviewed
and staff is in concurrence with the plat being acceptable. In
conclusion he said staff recommends approval.
Mayor Schmidt opened the public hearing. Mr. George Scott,
representative of Edgewater Terrace, Inc. explained he knows the
history of the subject property. He replied to a nursing home
inquiry, saying one had been proposed for the property but to
date the Planning & Zoning Department has no submittal for a
nursing home.
Doris Hill, of Lincoln Road stated she felt the property was not
adequate for high density residential. She thought the property
could be put to better use. The City Manager explained the exact
location of the proposed development for Ms. Hill. He said the
area fronting U.S.1 is being retained by the owner for commercial
and the development is low density residential as shown by the
lot size.
Councilwoman Rhodes said her concern is the water system and road
system overload along with other things that are overloaded
within the City. She said she is in favor of economic
development but at this point feels in may be at the expense of
our resources.
Additional discussion ensued regarding property rights.
Mayor Schmidt closed the public hearing and asked Council for
questions or comments. There being none he asked for a motion.
Councilman Brown moved for the approval of preliminary plat for
property located east of Coco Palm Drive, South of Pine Avenue
and west of U.S.1, seconded by Councilman Hammond. Motion
CARRIED 4-1 with Councilwoman Rhodes voting no.
D. 1st Reading, Ord. No. 2003-0-03, amending the Land
Page - 10 -
City Council Regular Meeting
March 17, 2003
--
."""",
Development Code in its entirety to be consistent with
recommendations made by staff, the Planning and Zoning Board and
Council
City Manager Hooper asked Ms. Matusick to read the title of the
Ordinance.
The City Manager then made reference to the overhead saying it is
much the same as the power point presentation that was reviewed
at the work session. He said the only change is the deletion of
the 16-foot height verses the 26-foot height. Also changed was
footprint size to state, in a commercial area with a non-
conforming use, if the property and structure were destroyed it
could be re-built to the same footprint. Additionally added, to
allow somebody to petition the Council for a variance to expand;
the Council may also consider waiving the application fee.
City Manager Hooper stated the appeals proposal seems to be the
most considered. He said presently the only appeals procedure is
from the Planning and Zoning Department for the granting
authority from the Boards. To make clear any confusion in wording
the following was added; any decision made by a City advisory
Board may be appealed to the City Council by the City Manager,
Mayor or City Attorney.
He said the rest of the changes have been reviewed chapter by
chapter as they were adopted. Mr. Hooper said there are no new
height restrictions (26-feet is currently in place) or no
additional setbacks. In each of those cases, if there is a
request it would go through the normal appeal process by way of a
variance that would go to the Planning and Zoning and appeals
would go to the City Council.
Mr. Hooper said the County has minimum setbacks or minimum
charter approved criteria that apply throughout the County and
Cities. He said they are waveable and are the same numbers as
ours; 25-feet from wetlands, some state in certain zones 50-feet
from the ordinary high. Mr. Hooper said Edgewater would comply
with those standards because that would be property any where
along the Indian River, south of the New Smyrna Beach/Edgewater
City limits. He said he is meeting with the County staff that
reviews and makes recommendations throughout the County. He will
propose that Edgewater contract with the County environmental
group to make recommendations so there will be environmentalist
from the County as well as the applicant's environmentalist
Page - 11 -
City Council Regular Meeting
March 17, 2003
'-"
.."""
recommendations.
Councilwoman Lichter questions whether there are different
setback requirements where sewers are involved. The City Manager
said the setbacks are the same, but those setbacks were
probably established when properties were on septic systems. He
said as central sewer has been introduced some setbacks have not
changed. Councilwoman Lichter acknowledged (she thinks) the
Council became aware for the first time that setbacks were
written in County language by County rules and regulations. The
City felt those rules should be implemented. She asked if the
City Manager meant the City would ask the County to help make
determinations to setbacks along waterfront property rather than
adhere strongly to the present setbacks. This would allow more
flexibility to various circumstances. City Manager Hooper said
the County would determine the viability of a wetland. He said
the remaining Riverside Drive vacant lots would be looked at
individually to see if they are buildable.
The City Manager offered to answer any other questions from the
public.
Jay Michael McKay, South Riverside Drive made reference to
Section 21-06.01 of the Land Development Code saying he commended
the Acting Community Development Director and the City Manager as
they are listening to the publics concerns. However, he thinks
writing changes into the code is problematic. He said it would
render all the work done by the Planning and Zoning Board
irrelevant if they could come in and have the power to veto all
the work that Planning and Zoning does.
Pat Card, 3019 Willow Oak Drive, stated, a big mistake would be
made codifying the right of staff to come before the Council with
questions reversing decisions of the duly constituted and sworn
boards of the City. The Boards are formed to provide the
citizens an opportunity to administer the codes of the City in a
reasonable manner, consistent with the standards of the
community. The purpose is to place the power to approve the
variances from the codes of the City in a reasonable and fair
manner. To keep the needs of the City citizens in the forefront
of each issue for variance. If the City is concerned about the
decisions made by members of the board then those members could
be replaced in accordance with the requirements of the law for
the replacement of members of those Boards. To be able to pick
and choose which decision a board makes and then reverse only
Page - 12 -
City Council Regular Meeting
March 17, 2003
...,
.""",
those that are not politically correct in your staffs view is
unacceptable. Mr. Card then gave some examples of changes that
could occur.
City Manager Hooper said over the past years the 25 feet and 50
feet has been adhered to. And maybe over the past five years
some have changed. He said there would be several requests
before them. There will be more environmental efforts for
definition.
Mr. Card asked if the remaining lots on Riverside Drive could be
looked at individually. Mr. Hooper said yes. There are probably
11 to 13 buildable lots left on Riverside Drive and maybe half of
those lots will not require some kind of variance. The other
half will probably require a variance to setbacks of either the
ordinary high water or setback to the wetlands.
The City Manager then asked for additional questions regarding
the Land Development Code.
Anton Heeb, 616 N. Riverside Drive, asked the Council to delete
the entire amendment. He said he believes the amendment is a
negative statement to a positive idea that a citizen is granted
the right of appeal by our City's code. Mr. Heeb explained there
are more than 20 references to appeal the Land Development Code
and only three basic reasons for making an appeal. He said he
realizes the amendment does not take away a citizens right to
appeal, but he feels very strongly that it does allow a City
Manager to circumvent the proper and correct process of an appeal
afforded the citizens of this City as is now provided by the
code. Mr. Heeb explained that a City Manager having that kind of
power written into the code is what he doesn't like. He feels
this way because the answer can be found under the current
section of appeals that states; appeals of the P&Z variance
decisions shall be made to the City Council in a manner and form
required by the City Council. The manner and form required by
the City Council is for an aggrieved party to submit a written
application submitted to the City Clerk with a fee of $150.00.
He said the amendment is not fair representation for the Citizens
as it allows the City Manager to decide which decisions he/she
likes he/she dislikes. Mr. Heeb feels we must be very careful as
to the content of any changes to our code, which he considers
disenfranchises our citizens.
Ferd Heeb, 115 N. Riverside Drive, said he is concerned with
Page - 13 -
City Council Regular Meeting
March 17, 2003
~
...,
putting something like this in black and white the next council
reading the Land Development Code they may think this is a
mandate for the City Manager to review what each board is doing.
A new City Manager may also see it as a mandate. Mr. Heeb said
what is happening is your telling the boards either do what staff
recommends or we will make the decision. He thinks that is
wrong. Mr. Heeb doesn't think this should be hanging over the
heads of the duly appointed citizens boards. The boards have
been asked to make decisions relative to community standards.
There being no further comments from the public, Mayor Schmidt
closed the public hearing and called for a motion.
Councilwoman Lichter commented to Mr. Cards comment about the
Code Enforcement Board. She said the Code Enforcement Board is
not an advisory board to the Council. She said the Boards
decision is a legal decision. Ms. Lichter said the Planning and
Zoning Board is an advisory board. The only final decision that
the Planning and Zoning Board may grant is for variances.
Discussion ensued regarding the City Managers duty in presenting
issues to the Council when he feels there is an inconsistency
with the code or with the policies of the City.
Both Councilman Hammond and Brown felt the added wording (the
City Manager) should be omitted. Councilwoman Rhodes said
stopping after "the interested partyU does nothing to change
that, it stills allows the City Manager and staff to have
Councils' "earU. Councilwoman Lichter stated she thinks it
should be rewritten. Mayor Schmidt said he thinks what he is
hearing is you can in essence do the same thing without the
additional wording.
Mayor Schmidt again asked for a motion.
Councilwoman Rhodes made a motion to approve Ordinance No. 2003-
0-03 to the exclusion of all the words after "interested partyU
in section 21-06.01 and to include the second option with 21-
71.01fb and 21-71.02el, second by Councilwoman Lichter. Motion
CARRIED 5-0.
Mayor Schmidt agreed to schedule the second reading for Ordinance
No. 2003-0-03 for the first meeting in May.
E. Res. No. 2003-R-03, Joint Participation Agreement between
the State of Florida Department of Transportation and the City of
Page - 14 -
City Council Regular Meeting
March 17, 2003
,.,.
...."
Edgewater for Landscaping Improvements along SR 442 from 1-95 to
US 1 (2 agreements at $50,000 each)
City Manager Hooper affirmed SR 442 originally was divided into
two separate construction contracts. The agreement was when the
two were combined we were entitled to $50,000.00 for landscaping
for each contract. The interlocal joint participation agreement
between the City and Department of Transportation. The sum is
over $100,000.00 to be spent along SSR 442 right-of-way for
beautification. He concluded stating staff recommends approval.
City Manager Hooper had Ms. Matusick read the Resolution into the
record.
The Mayor inquired whether any of the monies had already been
spent i.e. on the waterlines/irrigation lines that have been
installed. Director of Leisure Services, Jack Corder said this
is strictly for the purchase of plants, trees, shrubs, etc., not
for the use of installation or irrigation. None has been spent.
There being no comments from the public Mayor Schmidt closed the
public hearing.
Councilman Hammond moved to approve Resolution No. 2003-R-03,
second by Ms. Lichter. The motion CARRIED 5-0.
BOARD APPOINTMENTS
A. Planning and Zoning Board (2) - With the Board's
recommendations, Councilman Brown to consider reappointing Ed
Vopelak and Councilman Hammond to consider reappointing Bob
Garthwaite for additional 3-year terms
Councilman Brown moved to reappoint Ed Vopelak for the Planning
and Zoning Board, second by Councilwoman Rhodes. Motion CARRIED
5-0.
Councilman Hammond moved to reappoint Bob Garthwaite for
additional three years to the Planning and Zoning Board, second
by Councilwoman Rhodes. Motion CARRIED 5-0.
CONSENT AGENDA
A. Annual Authorization - Mayor or City Manager's authorization
for East Volusia Mosquito Control District to make low level
Page - 15 -
City Council Regular Meeting
March 17, 2003
'-'
..."
aerial inspection and spray flights
B. Law Enforcement Trust Funds - staff requesting approval to
use Trust Funds in the amount of $4,300.00 to purchase six (6)
Tasers and their associated equipment
C. Law Enforcement Trust Funds - staff requesting approval to
use Trust Funds in the amount of $500.00 to defray costs
associated with criminal investigative activities of CID
Councilman Brown moved to accept the consent agenda, second by
Councilwoman Lichter. Motion CARRIED 5-0.
OTHER BUSINESS
A. Adopt-A-Median Program - staff recommending approval for an
Adopt-A-Median program and instruct staff to implement and set up
a Reserve Fund for the program
City Manager Hooper stated the packet provided to Council shows
an outline with ranges between $1,000.00 and $3,000.00.
$1,000.00 is for a half of a small median and $3,000.00 is for a
whole large median. Business owners will be approached and if
they want to adopt there is an advertising recognition that is
included. The adoption provides for the maintenance and cleanup
of the median.
Director of Leisure Services, Jack Corder said there is an
existing map showing eight medians for adoption.
Councilwoman Lichter moved to accept the concept of the adoption
of the median, second by Councilman Brown. Motion CARRIED 5-0.
B. ParkTowne Industrial Center Phase I Change Order #3 - staff
requesting approval of Change Order #3 in the amount of
$228,478.77 and project closeout for Phase I (total final
contract price - $3,547,493.31)
City Manager Hooper made a staff presentation. He said this is
the final change order and with this closes out the project and
accepting ownership. Upon approval this will all be transferred
to the City (roads, water, sewer, lift station, drainage).
Councilwoman Rhodes moved to approve Change Order #3 and accept
Page - 16 -
City Council Regular Meeting
March 17, 2003
'-" ......".
the project, second by Councilwoman Lichter. Motion CARRIED 5-0.
OFFICER REPORTS
City Clerk Wadsworth had nothing to report at this time.
Paralegal Matusick informed the Council of a public hearing next
Wednesday night for the Animal Control Board starting at 7:00 PM.
City Manager Hooper reported the appraisal from Regions Bank is
back is at $2,000,000.00 which is higher than anticipated. Mr.
Hooper said they thought the amount would be half of the
appraisal amount. He said the surrounding property to the bank
has been sold making the site with the bank and the existing
parking all that is available. Mr. Hooper said he would continue
to talk with the bank and see what price he can bring back to the
Council. Also mentioned was the possibility of a lease.
CITIZEN COMMENTS/CORRESPONDENCE
None at this time.
ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business to discuss, Councilwoman Rhodes
moved to adjourn. The meeting adjourned at 10:07 p.m.
Minutes submitted by:
Sondra M. pengov
Page - 17 -
City Council Regular Meeting
March 17, 2003