09-12-2005 - Special Budget
~
..."",
CITY COUNCIL OF EDGEWATER
SPECIAL MEETING
SEPTEMBER 12, 2005
7:00 P.M.
COMMUNITY CENTER
MINUTES
CALL TO ORDER
Mayor Schmidt called the Special Meeting to order at 7:00 p.m. in
the Community Center.
ROLL CALL
Mayor Donald Schmidt
Councilman James Brown
Councilman Dennis Vincenzi
Councilwoman Harriet Rhodes
Councilwoman Judith Lichter
City Manager Kenneth Hooper
City Clerk Susan Wadsworth
Paralegal Robin Matusick
Present
Present
Present
Present
Present
Present
Present
Present
INVOCATION, PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
There was a silent invocation and pledge of allegiance to the
Flag.
MEETING PURPOSE
The purpose of the meeting was to hold public hearings (1st
Readings) on Ord. 2005-0-47, adopting final millage rate of 6.45
mills per $1,000 of assessed taxable value and Ord. 2005-0-48,
adopting final budget for fiscal year 2005/2006.
Paralegal Matusick read Ord. 2005-0-47 into the record.
City Manager Hooper made a staff presentation. He informed
Council tonight is the first public hearing of two for adoption
of the final budget. They are going to talk about the millage
and talk about the budget. The second public hearing will be
held September 26th.
City Manager Hooper stated when they last had a conversation
about the budget in a Work Session they went through and
described several issues and how they arrived at where they are
and what they are planning to do from that point. He stated he
described at that time we were half a million dollars out of
'-"
...."
budget. Several events have occurred since then. Each
department head was challenged with a five percent reduction
across the board, that got them about $400,000. He stated there
is an overall reduction in travel. He has eliminated any over
night, out-of-town travel. The only exception would be for those
individuals that have certificates. There is a little bit for
Council travel but Volusia Days has been eliminated to only one
Councilperson attending. They have also reduced other types of
travel. Promotional activities have also been reduced. He also
spoke of a reduction in books. There will be no legal books
purchased. Thirty thousand dollars has been cut from the
Economic Development Board budget. He spoke of adding personnel
to the Fire Department to reduce overtime. He spoke of sidewalk
maintenance that will come out of the development or impact fees
that will be brought forth by developers. He spoke of if we have
a retirement of one of the sergeants in the Police Department,
they will probably freeze that for a period of time to increase
some revenue. There is a good discussion of an administrative
function in the Police Department being unfunded. That is
probably the one that will have the largest repercussion that has
an actual layoff that would occur. Resurfacing they have brought
down from $500,000 down to $303,000. Out of that money they are
also doing Travelers Palm Drive in the amount of $168,000 before
the end of the month so they just reduced into next year's budget
by that same amount.
City Manager Hooper then went over the budget message regarding
Taxable Values, Problem Areas, Specific Budget Issues, Increase
of Staff, Water and Sewer Enterprise Fund, Stormwater Enterprise
Budget and Awarded Grants. (Attached) City Manager Hooper
recommended another year at the current millage rate of 6.45
mils.
City Manager Hooper then went over Page 5 of the Preliminary
Budget for Fiscal Year 2006 regarding the Summary of Funds.
Councilwoman Lichter asked City Manager Hooper where the Gas Tax
is. City Manager Hooper informed her it is into the General Fund
Budget. We use it for a lot of resurfacing and for maintenance.
We get about $450,000 to $480,000 of the Local Option Gas Tax
which comes back to us. They are eligible to use that for
anything related to roadways.
City Manager Hooper then went over Page 10 - Millage Rate
Analysis of the Preliminary Budget.
Page -2-
Council Special Meeting
September 12, 2005
'-" ...""
City Manager Hooper then went over Pages 13, 14 and 15 - General
Fund Budget Summary.
City Manager Hooper then went over Page 26 - Capital
Expenditures.
City Manager Hooper then informed Council the preliminary budget
has the same current millage rate and the overall dollars have
increased about $850,000 to the General Fund from taxes.
City Manager Hooper commented on the Revenues have indexing,
meaning October 1st these go up by a CPI number, which is about
3.4 and the other number for impact fees goes up about 4.2 or
4.3. Those numbers have been up as of April last year and
Council will see that jump even more. He informed Council we are
probably the only local city that has an annual indexing on rates
and the most important is on the development fees.
Councilwoman Rhodes asked about the shuffleboard clubhouse and
shuffleboard courts with lights and having to get insurance.
City Manager Hooper stated this is FEMA money coming back to the
City to replace and we also have insurance coming back. There is
about $500,000 worth of repairs and replacements the City is
doing. Councilwoman Rhodes clarified if there were things they
wanted to take off the capital expense list in order to lower the
millage rate there would be no point in taking the shuffleboard
items off. She spoke of the revenue being received for them and
not being able to use the money for anything else. City Manager
Hooper informed her that was correct. There is a portion that is
not paid by FEMA. There is about $100,000 the City will have to
pay.
Mayor Schmidt asked if the difference can be covered by
recreational impact fees. City Manager Hooper informed him no,
those are replacements. Recreational impact fees are only for
new and improved services, not for replacements. It is not
eligible for impact fees. If they were expanding the number of
courts they could take that out of it. They are putting back the
same number of courts and the same square footage of a building.
Councilwoman Rhodes then asked about the computer software for
Building, Planning and Code. City Manager Hooper explained those
are being paid for strictly out of building permit fees.
Councilwoman Rhodes stated she is trying to find something that
could help them reduce the millage rate.
Page -3-
Council Special Meeting
September 12, 2005
'-"
...".;
Councilwoman Lichter questioned the Library being a County
establishment but questioned if the parking lot is ours to fix.
City Manager Hooper stated it's two phases. The parking was ours
to fix for an expansion. The one the City built across the
street to the west is ours. The County maintains the building.
We maintain the parking and drainage that is outside. He
commented on the temporary fix done to the parking lot. Any
money in the budget for repairs now would be to go back and dig
it up and repair it.
Councilwoman Rhodes stated the $105,000 even though it comes out
of building permits that still figures into the total budget
figure. City Manager Hooper explained you can't use building
permits for anything other than the building department and the
support of the building department.
City Manager Hooper commented on it being difficult for the
Council to find something to cut because the budget has been
sliced to the bone. He then commented on the only thing Council
has are reserves. If they wanted to go to the reserves, he feels
this is futile at this point. That is the only thing Council
could remotely cut without either major dipping into service or
reduction of service to the public.
There was a brief discussion regarding the mid-year budget review
process. City Manager Hooper commented on this being an
appropriation of funds listing how they would like to spend the
money.
Mayor Schmidt expressed concern with cutting $30,000 out of the
Economic Development Board budget. City Manager Hooper commented
on the money for trips for the board members from last year that
was not used. He also spoke about setting aside dollars because
we share the position with New Smyrna Beach for an Economic
Development Director. Both of those to date have spent $10,000
out of the budget and that is what they went with. He has taken
the money and put it in reserves. If something comes along and
there is a need to spend money, that will come back to Council
and they can take those dollars from the reserves. If it were
budgeted in that department it can be moved anywhere through the
General Fund. When they are putting it in reserves, it will come
back to Council asking them to take it out of the general fund
reserve before it goes to a different department.
Page -4-
Council Special Meeting
September 12, 2005
--
..."",
Mayor Schmidt doesn't want to restrict them. City Manager Hooper
feels they aren't doing that. If there is an opportunity or need
to they can reallocate some of those dollars on a case-by-case
basis.
Councilwoman Rhodes asked why our impact fees don't earn any
interest. City Manager Hooper informed her they earn interest
but it is a fairly small amount.
Finance Director Jon Williams explained we operate under a pooled
cash system right now and at the end of the year they allocate
interest.
Councilwoman Rhodes asked if there is a proposed amount for 2006.
Mr. Williams explained it is guess work at this point. It is
better to tell the Council nothing and get a little bit at the
end then to come in and shoot high and not have anything.
City Manager Hooper referred to Page 21 and further commented on
the Economic Development Board Budget.
Mayor Schmidt opened the public hearing.
The following citizens spoke:
Mike Visconti, 316 Pine Breeze Drive, stated he is interested in
the garbage collection. He suggested we go from two garbage
pickups per week to one pickup per week with a standard container
throughout the City. He feels this would save half of the budget
in the long run. He spoke of only having one pickup per week in
Stratford, Connecticut where he came from. He lives in
Meadowlake and only brings his trash out once a week because he
doesn't accumulate that much garbage.
City Manager Hooper stated every time they have had the
discussion about privatization that is one of the big issues. By
far people want two pickups, they want the days they have and
they want their own buddies as garbagemen. Councilwoman Lichter
feels this is something the citizens seem very satisfied with.
She didn't agree with him regarding senior parks only having one
pickup. She lives in a community with over 500 homes and every
Monday and Thursday there is plenty that is put in front of the
homes.
Councilwoman Rhodes mentioned holding a public hearing on it to
see how the residents feel about it.
Page -5-
Council Special Meeting
September 12, 2005
'-'
....,
Domdnic Capri a , 606 Topside Circle, questioned why we are only
receiving 80% of the funds from FEMA when it was passed that it
be 90%, 75% FEMA, 15% State.
City Manager Hooper explained the difficulty has been trying to
reconcile all of the record keeping FEMA wants. They did make
what he feels was a political statement, that it would go from
about 80 to 90 at about the time we had the elections. It
sounded good but the roadblocks to get you to 90% are impossible
to achieve. Jon and his staff have been working, FEMA supplied
some individuals to help them get there. He commented on a
variety of issues FEMA has. The deal is going to be somewhere
between 78% and 80%, which is what they are going to get back.
Mr. Capri a stated he assumed the fact that we used our own people
on garbage pickup. That was in last year's budget so why should
that be a problem today. They had to spend that money in last
year's budget anyway. City Manager Hooper stated you aren't just
talking of not just their regular hours but the overtime as well.
For the three storm events, we used our people very quickly to
clear the roads and make way to get the power restored. The City
got reimbursed for the first seventy-two hours. They had a
choice, either am I getting reimbursed or opening up roads to the
public and they did the obvious answer and opened up as many
roads as quick as we could.
Councilwoman Rhodes stated she didn't think that is what Mr.
Capria is asking. She stated the money was spent on our people
was spent in last year's budget so why is it affecting this
year's budget. City Manager Hooper stated reimbursements. You
spent it last year. It came out of the general fund reserves and
depleted the $1.5 million down to zero so it impacts this year
because you are trying to build it back up.
Councilwoman Lichter feels maybe they should be asking for more
from FEMA. City Manager Hooper stated we have. We have been
appealing and going through the process of constant updating. He
stated they have probably changed program managers five times.
Every time it changes hands you start over. They change the
rules.
Councilwoman Rhodes feels they have to budget like we aren't
getting any money from FEMA. City Manager Hooper stated this
budget has what FEMA has signed off on and agreed.
Page -6-
Council Special Meeting
September 12, 2005
--
"""'"
David Chess, 209 Oak Branch Drive, stated he was in Deland today
and picked up a copy of the Deacon. It was interested to him to
note DeBary's tentative budget which is $21 million and they
decided not to roll back but they are at 2.5% millage rate and he
thought this City Council should take a look at that and ask
ourselves why we are at 6.45.
Councilwoman Rhodes stated DeBary doesn't have half the services
we do. That is part of it.
John Cordeiro, 1515 Pine Tree Drive, stated he happens to have a
copy of Deltona's budget and he is sure the Council has looked at
it and he is sure they would have to be ashamed of themselves to
see what Edgewater's budget is and see what Deltona's it.
Deltona is going to have a $4.2 million reserve and they are
going to build a $1.2 million fire station and are going to
supply it with $450,000 for equipment and nine new firemen. He
thinks there is something wrong with the way the City is handling
the taxpayers money. He feels they should take a trip to Deltona
and find out. Their millage is only 4.15. There is something
definitely wrong.
Councilwoman Lichter stated when Florida Shores went in there
were no roads and no sewers. When that got mandated to be done
by the State the rest of us in our tax base are paying a 1/3 of
that price. Each neighbor on both sides of the street in Florida
Shores is paying a 1/3 for their roads to be paved and 1/3 for
their sewers to be put in. The rest of the City are picking up
the other 1/3. That is part of it. We aren't doing that with
developments any longer. They are paying for themselves. The
handshake or however that large development went in is part of
the reason that is so.
Mr. Cordeiro then commented on flood control and all of the
canals in Florida Shores. He questioned this helping flood
control. He stated they are all full of trees and branches and
if we ever had a Katrina here Edgewater and Oak Hill would be
history. He asked if there is any way the City can clean these
out. Mayor Schmidt informed him the City is out there every day
working on ditches. Mr. Cordeiro feels if they are all clogged
up with trees and branches it is going to be a problem if we get
a bad hurricane with a surge.
Mr. Cordeiro stated even with the roads and sewers it still
doesn't justify what Deltona does and what this City does. There
is definitely something wrong here some people that are running
the finances with the taxpayers money.
Page -7-
Council Special Meeting
September 12, 2005
'-'
..."
Councilwoman Lichter informed Mr. Cordeiro the Councilmembers are
taxpayers too. Councilwoman Rhodes stated the millage rate was
more before the current Council was here.
City Manager Hooper stated there is a subsidiary incurring. It
runs out and probably has another six or seven years and you will
see some of this dropping off but there is a large subsidy and
well worth it. Part of that is being paid for by the City
overall for it's millage rate and Deltona doesn't have the same
level of service.
Debra Rogers, 510 S. Riverside Drive, stated initially the
shuffleboard clubhouse had to be knocked down and cleaned up
within seventy-two hours so we could get 100% money from FEMA.
She heard later we are going to get 80% money because we aren't
building the shuffleboard courts at Kennedy Park but at Rotary
Park instead. She asked if that is the reason we are only
getting 80%.
City Manager Hooper stated it is a depreciated amount. Those
shuffleboard courts were put in twenty years ago. FEMA
reimbursed 100% of what was submitted within the seventy-two
hours of what they were worth. Rebuilding costs a lot more.
Ms. Rogers asked how many times they submitted the worksheets to
FEMA before they kicked them back. Finance Director Williams
stated we have submitted several variations of project
worksheets. They compile the costs and submit them. They corne
back and said you have classified this expense as an emergency
protective measure. It's really not considered emergency
protective measure and it's considered this and we are going to
disallow it. So you have to go back through recompute and
resubmit and if they find something else the process starts all
over.
Ms. Rogers asked if we have certain personnel on staff that are
familiar with the FEMA forms so that in the future if this
happens we don't have these kickbacks and the possibility of
losing percentages.
Mayor Schmidt asked if it was the FEMA people that were filling
out the reports and turning them in for the most part. We gave
them the information, they filled them out, turned them into
their own organization and their organization would kick them
back and ask for other information.
Page -8-
Council Special Meeting
September 12, 2005
...,.
'"
City Manager Hooper commented on the FEMA staff constantly
changing. City staff attended classes. It was very
discouraging. He spoke of being treated better than most other
cities. We got a higher percentage than most of the other cities
around that were able to get to those forms. We were able to
land some things outside, some preventative measures.
Ms. Rogers commented on the millage and the one percent increase
in 2002. It was an increase, a large part of it had to do with
the shortfall in the pension. Last year they were given back a
half a point. We still have that half a point sitting there
because of the pension shortfall from 2002. What is going on
with that, especially now that we have another shortfall in the
pension. She believes this has a large part to do with this
budget and the millage staying exactly as it was last year.
City Manager Hooper stated the changes they are looking at are
either ending the pension plan as we know it today, which is a
very significant change of doing business, hiring consultants to
look at better investments or making recommendations to change
those plans. Those are the steps we are taking.
Ms. Rogers asked in our current budget do we have numbers to pay
for these consultants. City Manager Hooper informed her yes.
Mayor Schmidt closed the public hearing.
Councilman Brown feels the budget has been cut to the bare bone.
He doesn't see where they can cut anymore on it. He likes the
idea of having $2.68 million back into the reserves at the end of
the year. He feels this is encouraging.
Councilman Vincenzi stated he would be asking questions about the
reserves in the next week or two. When the city meets with
financial problems, it's difficult to maintain the services the
way we have them and still keep taxes level or even reduce them.
When that type of situation comes up, he feels what is needed is
a little radical alignment. One of the things that everybody
doesn't want to touch is trash collection but that is one area
where people could save a lot of money and the City could save a
lot of money. Especially in the coming years because we are
expanding so much and that is one thing that will have to expand
along with it. That is one of the easiest things the City can
privatize out. He feels the City could get the right contractor
for a significant reduction in cost and you could eliminate that
department at $2 million per year.
Page -9-
Council Special Meeting
September 12, 2005
~
~
City Manager Hooper commented on a summary done by Ponce Inlet.
Pretty much the average around was $12 or $13. Ours is around
$19. There is $2.2 or $2.3 million in the solid waste refuse
fund. The savings wouldn't be to the City's tax fund because
that is an enterprise fund but there would certainly be savings
to the individual people.
Councilman Vincenzi stated so they would see a little increase in
taxes but they would see a reduction in other services. He feels
this is something that needs to be looked at along with other
areas as well. He feels the only thing that should not be
touched is Police and Fire. They are needed for public safety.
They are there and do a good job and they should get what they
need to operate.
Councilwoman Rhodes stated we did look privatizing garbage and
this room was full of people in an uproar. They didn't want
their garbage messed with. Councilman Vincenzi stated sometimes
you have to make touch decisions. Councilwoman Rhodes stated but
you represent a population and you have to do that to the best of
your ability.
Councilman Vincenzi stated you don't know that those 200 people
represent the sediment of the people in Edgewater. You think you
do but you don't know for sure.
Mayor Schmidt asked City Manager Hooper to put this on his
calendar.
Councilwoman Rhodes stated in 1998 our millage rate was 6.44
mills. Right now our millage rate is 6.45. Over those years
it's gone down and it's gone up and it depends on what is going
on in the City, what we need in order to make things work, to
provide the services that our citizens rely on and how much it
costs to do that. More than anybody, she would really love to
take this back to the 5.95 but she doesn't think it's feasible to
do that. She feels they put themselves in a bind with the
Charter if they do that because it comes out of our reserve funds
and the Charter, which they swore to uphold, requires that we
have those reserve funds. She feels they don't have a choice.
Councilwoman Lichter commented on being a senior and having
served this City, either on the Planning and Zoning Board or on
Council, for the last fifteen years. She thinks this is the best
they can do at the time.
Page -10-
Council Special Meeting
September 12, 2005
....
.."",
Councilwoman Lichter feels because you are budgeting it doesn't
mean you have to spend it but at least it's there if we need it.
The City was, when she moved here, not as attractive as it is
now. That costs money. She feels the City has come a long way.
She will be voting for this budget because she feels a lot of
effort has gone into it. If she wants to go to the State meeting
with the other representative she will pay her own way because
she feels that is a very important one.
Mayor Schmidt thanked Finance Director Williams for all of this
hard work. He spoke about a few years ago when they said to the
voters we needed 6.95 mills and went up a full mill that year and
they said if they give that to the City we will spend it wisely
and get it back to the citizens over the next few years. He
would love to sit next to Councilwoman Rhodes and say 5.95 this
year. He said when they asked for the extra mill they also
didn't ask for three hurricanes. He asked if they split the
difference from where we are now to the rest of the mill, can a
budget be worked out with a 6.2 millage rate.
Councilwoman Rhodes asked what that would give them in the
reserve fund. City Manager Hooper stated it is about $140,000 to
$150,000 out of the reserve account. He would like to get
Council to approve this tonight, tell him they want him to look
at that and bring back to Council at the second hearing and let
them know if they wanted to do it at that number here is what
would occur. He reminded Council, they can not raise the number
but they can always go down.
CounciLwoman Rhodes moved to set the miLLaqe rate at 6.45, and
CounciLwoman Lichter incLuded approvinq Ord. 2005-0-47 and Ord.
2005-0-48, second bv CounciLwoman Lichter.
Mayor Schmidt confirmed that City Manager Hooper would be
bringing back figures for a proposal of 6.2 mills.
Mayor Schmidt asked Councilwoman Rhodes if it was okay to include
that in her motion. Councilwoman Rhodes agreed.
The MOTION CARRIED 5-0.
ADJOURNMENT
Mayor Schmidt called a ten-minute recess before the Regular
Meeting.
Page -11-
Council Special Meeting
September 12, 2005
~
The meeting recessed at 8:02 p.m.
Minutes submitted by:
Lisa Bloomer
Page -12-
....",
Council Special Meeting
September 12, 2005
...... .....,
THE CITY OF EDGE WA TER
POST OFFICE BOX 100. EDGEWATER, FLORIDA 32132-0100
INTER-OFFICE MEMORANDUM
EDGEWATER, FLORIDA
TO: Mayor and City Council I j ~Lk
FROM: Ken Hooper, City Manager JI.'r
C.M. NO: 2005-129
DATE: September 9,2005
SUBJECT: FY 2005-2006 Budget
Attached is the proposed City of Edgewater budget for the fiscal year October 1, 2005 through
September 30, 2006. Staff is pleased to present a general fund budget that is balanced and is
consistent with the Charter requirements concerning unrestricted reserve fund balance. Several
assumptions and issues concerning this proposed budget should be described.
1. TAXABLE VALUE
The acreage of the City of Edge water is expanding through voluntary annexations. The City
has experienced a growth rate of approximately 200 new housing units for FY 2004-2005.
The City is also experiencing growth of commercial/industrial development. The US 1
corridor is undergoing in-fill development and is expected to receive redevelopment pressure
as the vacant property is developed. With the completion of the widening of SR442,
development pressure has increased particularly around the 1-95/SR442 interchange.
Taxable values for the City have increased 20.72% during the current fiscal year. This is a
significant increase in value. The City has averaged a 9.38% increase in taxable values
during the period 1998-2005. The increase in taxable value is expected to increase with the
development of Park Towne Industrial Center, US1 corridor, I-95/SR442 interchange and the
area west ofI-95. Annexations and land use changes have created the potential of 10,000
new housing units and 1.5 million square feet of commercial development over the next
decade.
The increase in taxable values includes new construction and increased value to current
properties/structures. New growth for the proposed budget is 250 new housing units and 25
acres of industrial property located at ParkTowne Industrial Center. (Note the 20.72%
increase for FY2005/06 does not include any development or sales in ParkTowne Industrial
Center as they will be included in next year's taxable value.)
eM 2005-129
I:\liz_ docs\memo\FY2005-06 Budget
".,
....,
FY 2005-2006 Budget
September 9, 2005
Page 2
In summary, the City has invested in infrastructure (Airpark Road and ParkTowne) and is witnessing
the results in increased taxable value. This will continue to escalate as ParkTowne is developed.
Based on improvements to the Land Development Code, the City is gaining taxable values in new
subdivisions that are modem, self-supporting and paying their fair share for the cost of growth. The
City of Edge water has the highest impact fees (growth driven revenue) in V olusia County. The City
of Edgewater passes the cost of development review, engineering inspections and certification
directly to the developer.
2. PROBLEM AREAS
a. Hurricanes 2004/2005 - The City of Edgewater spent approximately $5.5 million in
debris removal and structure repair/replacement due to the three (3) hurricanes. FEMA
will reimburse the City approximately $4.0 million and the City has depleted
approximately $1.5 million from its general fund reserves. The proposed budget
contains $1.5 million as an appropriated general fund reserve.
The City issued approximately 2,000 building permits for roof repairs and other
structural repairs due to hurricane damage. The City has taken strong preventative
measures (generators, swale cleaning and weather-proofing) to reduce future storm
damage. Our citizens were rewarded with a very proactive storm response effort.
b. Pension Plans - The City has in place four local-plan pension plans for the employees.
· Police Pension (Defined Benefit)
· Fire Pension (Defined Benefit)
· General Fund (Defined Benefit)
· General Fund 40lA (Defined Contribution)
All Defined Benefit Plans are based on the principal that when an employee retires from
City employment, the employee will be entitled to a retirement benefit package that is
based on the number of years of service, a fixed multiplier and an average of the
employee's most highly compensated salaried years.
The funding necessary to maintain a functional benefit plan is derived from investment
earning of the funds within the plan, a contribution by the participating member and the
City provides the balance of the revenue to keep the plan fully funded. In theory, the
earnings from investing the fund balance of the planes) should provide most of the
funding with the employees contributing a range of2.5 to 6% and the City contributing
approximately 15%. This has worked successfully for several years until investment
earnings dropped substantially following the 9-11 stock market drop.
To keep the defined benefit plans fully funded, the City currently must contribute 42%
of annual salaries for the general employees' plan, 29.79% for the police plan and
16.4% for the fire plan.
eM 2005-129
I:\liz _ docs\memo\FY2005-06 Budget
.,....
.."""
FY 2005-2006 Budget
September 9,2005
Page 3
The defined contribution plan is not based on market (interest earnings) conditions. The
City contributes 12% of the employees salary to the defined contribution plan and the
employee can contribute based on their individual financial conditions. The employt:e
also selects how their retirement funds are invested.
The City's management team will be reviewing options to better control this escalating
expense. Bogdahn Consulting, an independent consulting firm, has been retained to
review the three (3) defined benefit plans.
c. Investment Income - The City invests its funds in conservative/sound revenue
producing accounts. During the recent "slow-down" of the economy since the 9-11
event, the rate of return has steadily dropped to approximately 1.5% or less. Prior to 9-
11, the City gained an earning of 6-8% on its investments. This is a substantial loss of
annual revenue which effects the general fund.
c. Insurance Rates - Health insurance for the employees and their spouses continue to
rise. The annual increase for the proposed budget is 5%. This has a significant impact
on the City's budget.
d. Fuel Costs - The cost of fuel continues to rise and will cost approximately 25% more
for FY2005/2006.
e. Construction Costs - The cost of infrastructure improvements (roads, utilities, parks,
resurfacing and concrete) continues to rise at a rate of approximately 2-3% per month.
3. SPECIFIC BUDGET ISSUES
Capital ExpenditureslReplacementslReserves
· attached list
4. INCREASE OF STAFF
There is a need to expand the garbage pick~up by the addition of another route. This will
require the addition of 1 driver and 2 pick-up personnel. This addition of a new route will
require a new garbage truck. In 2005 City Council approved the creation of an Animal
Services Administrator, Residential Building Inspector, three (3) additional firefighters,
Administrative Secretary for Environmental Services, Maintenance Worker for Leisure
Services, Community Service Officer and Wastewater Collections Service Worker.
5. WATER AND SEWER ENTERPRISE FUND
By the beginning ofFY2006, the reclaimed rate system improvements (Phase I) and the radio
read meter installations program will be complete and operational and will provide for
increased revenue by accurately metering both potable and reclaimed water usage. The new
budget includes construction of two (2) new potable water production wells and the
acquisition of approximately 18 acres from V olusia County to serve as a storage and
eM 2005-129
I:\liz_docs\memo\FY2005-06 Budget
~
""""
FY 2005-2006 Budget
September 9,2005
Page 4
repumping station for both potable and reclaimed water, as well as provide a site for the new
animal facility. Improved lime sludge handling facilities and disinfection system
improvements are budgeted for the Alan R. Thomas Water Treatment Plant.
6. STORMW A TER ENTERPRISE BUDGET
Based on annual revenues and expenses, this fund is also programmed to be a deficit and will
require the use of general fund reserves to balance the fund. Currently 50% of the
stormwater utility fee is dedicated to the debt service for drainage improvements within the
Florida Shores subdivision and 50% of the stormwater utility fee is used for the city-wide
stormwater maintenance program. The City will continue with its Master Stormwater Plan
this year but without an increase in storm water revenue, no funds will be available to
implement the master plan.
Where benefits to regional stormwater problems can be demonstrated, the SJRWMD and
FIND offer matching grant funds. The City is currently using a SJRWMD grant to fund the
current segment of the Master Stormwater Plan. During FY2005/2006, the City must expand
the city-wide master stormwater plan to include the recently annexed areas. The cost of the
stormwater plan is passed on the new development. Additional funds for capital stormwater
infrastructure projects are available with matching funds and the City has a grant application
pending with the. SJR WMD for the Eastern Shores (Rowe) Industrial Park area..
7. AWARDED GRANTS
The City has received approximately $3 million in grants from federal, state, County and
special districts during FY2003-2005. (See attached for specific awards.)
In summary, the proposed general fund budget is sound and we have proposed reimplementing
programs (resurfacing and vehicle replacements, funded reserve balance) that were eliminated or
reduced during FY 2002/2003 and FY 2004/2005 due to hurricanes. I recommend another year at
the current millage (6.45 mill) and predict that revenue will continue to increase during FY 2005-
2006 allowing the option of a reduced millage rate for FY 2006-2007.
KRH:ejm
Attachments
eM 2005-129
I:\Iiz_docs\memo\FY2005-06 Budget
"-"
GENERAL FUND CAPITAL EXPENSE
UPGRADE BLDG/OFFICE-NEW DOORS ETC
CITY HALL - TELEPHONE SYSTEM, HANDSETS, WIRING ETC
FILE SERVER - FIRE DEPT
ANTIVIRUS FOR CLIENTS, MAIL SERVER, SERVERS (RENEWAL)
OFF SITE WEB SITE AND DOMAIN NAME
2 CISCO CATALYST 3750-24TS-S SWITCH @2900
5 SLR-I00 TAPES @ 100
2 FIBER OPTIC NETWORK TRANSCEIVERS @169
MISC. (CABLES, NETWORK CARDS, HARD DRIVES)
SERVER RACK
COMPUTER SOFTWARE - BUILDING, PLANNING & CODE
2005 FIRE GRANT (TANKER TRUCK) CITY MATCH -FIRE
4 CROWN VICTORIA POLICE CRUISERS
12 PASSENGER VAN FIRE
FORD EXPLORER ANIMAL SERVICES
F150 TRUCK COMMUNITY SERVICES
F150 TRUCK BUILDING TOTAL FOR 5 YR LEASE
FORD EXPLORER 4X4 POLICE TOTAL LEASE
REPLACE 7 800 MHZ RADIOS
Stair Chair
UHF/VHF Radio for S-55 & R-57
Emitters for D-55, S-55, R-57
Monitor Upgrade for ETC02
FireCom System for New E-55 & R-57
FIRE GRANT 2005 CARRYOVER (FIRE GEAR)
800 mhz Radios (replacement)
BUSH HOG MOWER
MOWING TRACTOR
MECHANICS TOOL BOX
SHUFFLEBOARD CLUBHOUSE
WSP RESURFACE (4) TENNIS COURTS
SIDEWALK REPAIRS (APPROX. 50 LOCA nONS)
LIBRARY PARKING LOT REPAIRS
SHUFFLEBOARD COURTS W/LIGHTS
RACQUETBALL COURTS
JOHN DEERE 2653A 3WD REEL MOWER/EXTRA SET BLADES
FORKLIFT SET
TOTAL
.....,
3,000
50,000
5,000
1,000
400
5,800
500
338
2,000
1,500
105,000
20,000
LEASE
LEASE
LEASE
LEASE
LEASE
54,104
19,720
2,000
2,700
1,200
12,500
2,900
2,730
3,500
2,700
17,600
2,000
120,000
14,000
8,000
6,000
217,000
96,000
29,525
1,060
809,777
'-'
""-tIll
LEISURE SERVICES DEPARTMENT
GRANT AWARDS
FIND (03)
Kennedy Park & Pier
PORT DISTRICT (03)
Dredge/Boat House/Dock
ECHO (03)
ECHO (05)
CDBG (02/03)
CDBG (03/04)
Hawks Park Phase III
Hawks Park Phase III-A
ParkTowne Industrial Center
Stormwater Improvements
CDBG (04/05)
Road Resurfacing (Riverside/Shangri-Ia)
CDBG (05/06)
FRDAP (05)
Stormwater Improvements
Hawks Park Phase III
PEOPLE FOR DRUG
FREE YOUTH (05)
Day at the Park
PEOPLE FOR DRUG
FREE YOUTH (05)
Hats for Baseball
TOTAL
FIND - Florida Inland Navigation District
PORT DISTRICT - Ponce De Leon Inlet & Port District
ECHO - Volusia County
FRDAP - Florida Recreation Development Assistance Program
CDBG - Community Development Block Grant (Federal)
J:il$'c
~/'~
SEp () (I ~ y~()
C/J-y .((}(}j'
114 t1I.
'40~-9
$ 60,885
$110,165
$386,294
$ 83,175
$104,196
$105,564
$101,726
$ 96,639
$141,617
$ 4,000
$ 2,300
$1,196,561