Loading...
3219 Yule Tree Drive - Tyler, Robin - 08-29-2012 - $834.81 - SAT 2/10/20222/10/2022 2:00:08 PM Instrument #2022032474 #1 Book:8201 Page:4820 Laura E. Roth, Volusia County Clerk of Court CORRECTED SATISFACTION OF CITY OF EDGEWATER UTILITIES LIEN ROBIN A. TYLER KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS: That the City Council of the City of Edgewater, Florida, pursuant to the provisions of Chapter 19, Code of Ordinances, City of Edgewater, Florida, on August 29, 2012 filed a Lien and on August 6, 2015 filed a Satisfaction against property owned by ROBIN A. TYLER and described as: Lots 914149 & 14150, Block #456, Florida Shores #24 Rev, MB 19, PG 244 per OR 4677, PGS 1656-1657 per OR 5625, PG 0756 in the public records of Volusia County, Florida (Property location: 3219 Yule Tree Drive, Edgewater, FL), Parcel 48402-01-14-1490 {Location ID #8473) in the amount of EIGHT HUNDRED THIRTY-FOUR and 81/100 dollars ($834.81) plus interest, filing fees, and any other costs incurred by the City; said Lien being recorded in Official Records Book 6753, Page 136 and Satisfaction in Official Records Book 7148, Pape 2813 of the Public Records of Volusia County, Florida. The City does hereby acknowledge full payment and satisfaction thereof and hereby consents that the same shall be discharged and satisfied of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the City of Edgewater, acting by and through its City Manager, has executed this instrument this 10`x' day of February, 2022. WITNESSES: CITY OF EDGEWATER, FLORIDA i J B , y. Glenn A. Irby City Manager Signed, sealed and delivered in the presence of: STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF VOLUSIA I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this day, before me, an officer duly authorized in the State and County aforesaid to take acknowledgments, personally appeared GLENN A. IRBY, City Manager for the City of Edgewater, who is duly authorized to execute this document on behalf of the City of Edgewater, Florida, and is personally known to me and who executed the foregoing instrument and acknowledged before me that he/she executed the same. WITNESS my hand and official seal in the County and State last aforesaid this 10`I' day of February, 2022. 0*; ,• =ML N 442679 ,} 025lnsuranC080O. gS-704 Notary Public {SeallStainp} ���" {Commission Expiration Date) State of Florida at Large **This Corrected satisfaction of Utility Lien is being recorded to reflect the correct legal description. This Corrected Satisfaction will replace that recorded on March 21, 2018 and located at Official Records Book #7522, Page 1724. 3121/2018 12:48:13 PM Instrument#2018057356#1 Book:7522 Page:1724 Laura E. Roth,Volusia County Clerk of Court CORRECTED SATISFACTION OF CITY OF EDGEWATER UTILITIES LIEN ROBIN A.TYLER KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS: That the City Council of the City of Edgewater, Florida, pursuant to the provisions of Chapter 19,Code of Ordinances, City of Edgewater, Florida, on August 29, 2012 filed a Lien and on August 6, 2015 filed a Satisfaction against property owned by ROBIN A. TYLER and described as: Lots #14149 & 14150, Block #456, Florida Shores #24 Rev, MB 19, PG 244 per OR 4677, PGS 1656-1657 per OR 5625, PG 0756 per D/C OR 6797, PG 0149 in the public records of Volusia County, Florida (Property location: 3219 Yule Tree Drive, Edgewater, FL), Parcel#8402-01-14-1490(Location ID#8473) in the amount of EIGHT HUNDRED THIRTY-FOUR and 81/100 dollars (5834.81) plus interest, filing fees, and any other costs incurred by the City; said Lien being recorded in Official Records Book 64 6753,Page 136 and Satisfaction in Official Records Book 7148,Page 2813 of the Public Records of Volusia County, Florida. The City does hereby acknowledge full payment and satisfaction thereof and hereby consents that the same shall be discharged and satisfied of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF,the City of Edgewater, acting by and through its City Manager, has executed this instrument this 15th day of March,2018. WITNESSES: CITY OF EDGEWATER,FLORIDA X-YyNa \k_ a%tom JC, / Tra y T. :arlow C0 Manager Signed,sealed and delivered in the presence of: STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF VOLUSIA I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this day, before me, an officer duly authorized in the State and County aforesaid to take acknowledgments, personally appeared TRACEY T. BARLOW, City Manager for the City of Edgewater, who is duly authorized to execute this document on behalf of the City of Edgewater, Florida, and is personally known to me and who executed the foregoing instrument and acknowledged before me that he/she executed the same. WITNESS my hand and official seal in the County and State last aforesaid this 18th day of March,2018. . (Seal/Stamp) Notary Public (Commission Expiration Date) State of Florida at La ***This CORRECTED SATISFACTION is being recorded to reflect the correct Official Records Book as 6753 NOT 6754. This Corrected Satisfaction of Utility Lien will rept 1Iti t t VITelEtrnn August 6,2015 and located at Official Records Book#7148,Page 2813. «"'"+ :: KELSEY D.ARCIERI Commission#GG 132663 _ Expires August B.2021 •.?. ' =.-.G Bonded 1MJ Troy=ein Insurance 800-365-703 (I.iensiUtilityLien-SATISFACTION—CORRECTED-Tyler-3219YuleTree#4-March20I B) 08/06/2015 03:34 PH Instrument# 2015-145790 # 1 Book: 7148 Page: 2813 SATISFACTION OF CITY OF EDGEWATER Diane N. Natousek UTILITIES LIEN Volusia County, Clerk of Court ROBIN A. TYLER KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS: That the City Council of the City of Edgewater, Florida, pursuant to the provisions of Chapter 19, Code of Ordinances, City of Edgewater, Florida, on September 29, 2012 filed a Lien against property owned by ROBIN A. TYLER and described as: Lots #14149 & 14150, Block #456, Florida Shores #24 Rev, MB 19, PG 244 per OR 4677, PGS 1656-1657 per OR 5625, PG 0756 in the public records of Volusia County, Florida (Property location: 3219 Yule Tree Drive, Edgewater, FL), Parcel #8402-01-14-1490 (Location ID #8473) in the amount of EIGHT HUNDRED THIRTY-FOUR and 81/100 dollars ($834.81) plus interest, filing fees, and any other costs incurred by the City; said Lien being recorded in Official Records Book 6754, Page 136 of the Public Records of Volusia County, Florida. The City does hereby acknowledge full payment and satisfaction thereof and hereby consents that the same shall be discharged and satisfied of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the City of Edgewater, acting by and through its City Manager, has executed this instrument this 5th day of August, 2015. WITNESSES: Signed, sealed and delivered in the presence of: STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF VOLUSIA CITY OF EDGEWATER, FLORIDA By: Tra`y6y T. Barlow Ci# Manager I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this day, before me, an officer duly authorized in the State and County aforesaid to take acknowledgments, personally appeared TRACEY T. BARLOW, City Manager for the City of Edgewater, who is duly authorized to execute this document on behalf of the City of Edgewater, Florida, and is personally known to me and who executed the foregoing instrument and acknowledged before me that he/she executed the same. WITNESS my hand and official seal in the County and State last aforesaid this 5th day of August, 2015. (Seal/Stamp) (Commission Expiration Date) Notary Public State of Florida at Large Cn o #EE 883206 yraf��y iilFl 1910E C (Liens/UtilityLien-SATISFACTION—Tyler-3219YuleTree#4-August-2015) LIEN RESEARCH AND ASSESSMENT PAYOFF WORKSHEET FOR OFFICE USE ONLY City of Edgewater — Finance Department P.O. Box 100 - Edgewater, FL 32132-0100 COMPLETED (386) 424-2400 ext. 1306 - Fax (386) 424-2409 Updated:_7 ' �1% (5 *Overnight address: 104 N. Riverside Dr., Edgewater, FL 32132 Initials: www.cityotedgewater.org jPROPERTY INFORMATION * PARCEL ID # (short): * PROPERTY ADDRESS: -3t'f__ � wl 0 {) 1 1— Q _ by . * LEGAL DESCRIPTION: * PRESENT OWNER: L * FROM: (company) (name) * Select method to receive completed form: email address: LIEN 9P-UT CODE ENFORCEMENT: LOT CLEARING: ALARM FEE FINES AND LIENS Does not Include Utilities FINE/citation INTEREST AfR 9Q * CLOSING DATE: * DATE REQUESTED: *PHONE Fax RECORDING FRE- TOTAL. �3 9 � C A o, PAYOFF GOOD THRU: FINES AND LIENS TOTALS:! SERVICE ACCOUNT NUMBER:^�(J _ b`C�UTILITY DEPOSIT: - LAST PAYMENT RECEIVED: - UTILITIES DUE: (Includes Liens) SERVICE THRU: // l J[ - - INTEREST (9Q) : NEXT BILL DATE: 01 RECORDING FEES (9M): INTEREST CALCULATED TO DATE: UTILITY AND FEE TOTALS: I ki GRAND TOTAL: PLEASE RETAIN A COPY FOR YOUR RECORDS LIEN RESEARCH AND PAYOFF WORKSHEET City of Edgewater — Finance Department „Y P.O. Box 100 • 104 N. Riverside Drive EEC GE WA TE R Edgewater, FL 32132-0100 (386) 424-2400 ext. 1305 - Fax (386) 424-2409 A FEE OF $30.00 IS REQUIRED FOR ALL RESEARCH www.cityotedgewater.org ITEMS MARKED WITH AN *MUST BE COMPLETED PROPERTY INFORMATION FOR OFFICE USE ONLY Payment Updated CON Date: Initials: * PARCEL ID # (short): 840201141490 * CLOSING DATE: 7/20/15 * PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3219 Yule Tree Drive * OWNERS NAME: * FROM: (company) Bank of New York Mellon William J Gardner PA (name) Kandi * DATE REQUESTED: 7/14/15 *phone # 561-750-7778 Select method to receive completed form: *email address: precloser@wjgardnerlaw.com or *Fax # 561-750-6515 FINES AND LIENS Does not Include Utilities PER DAY FINEicitation INTEREST RECORDING FEE TOTAL 9P-UT CIF 9Q 9U CODE ENFORCEMENT: LOT CLEARING: NUISANCE ABATEMENT: ALARM LIEN: INTEREST GOOD THRU: _ UTILITY SE ACCOUNT NUMBER: ���✓"'S —i t� �� LAST PAYMENT RECEIVED.t SERVICE THRU: NEXT BILL DATE: INTEREST GOOD THRU: f FINES AND LIENS TOTALS:., (L� ,JD DEPOSIT: rt UTILITIES DUE: (Includes Liens) INTEREST: 9QP RECORDING FEES: 9M,(()� UTILITY AND FEE TOTALS: FINES, LIENS AND UTILITY FEES GRAND TOTAL: PLEASE ALLOW 3-5 BUSINESS DAYS FOR YOUR REQUEST TO BE COMPLETED PLEASE RETAIN A COPY FOR YOUR RECORDS PLEASE NOTE ALL PAYMENTS TO SETTLE LIENS MUST BE SENT TO OUR OFFICE. City of Edgewater, PO Box 100 Edgewater, FI 32132 overnight: 104 N. Riverside Dr., Edgewater, FI 32132 ON-LINE/PHONE PAYMENTS CANNOT BE PROCESSED TO SATISFY LIENS PAYMENT INFORMATION By signing belo 1 he by authori the Ci �f Edgewater to charge $30.00 for the Lien Research for the property described above: Date: 7/14/15 SIGNATURE: _ _ ., (,G lk Print Name Kandi Jollay 'CHECK #:' L jz-�'. L I *Payment must be received prior to research completion. ' *Overnictht address: 104 N. Riverside Dr., Edgewater, FL 32132 CARD TYPE: VISA ❑MASTERCARD H AMERICAN EXPRESS Q DISCOVER II CARD NUMBER: SECURITY CODE: EXP DATE: BILLING ADDRESS* (required): city, state, zip code Q W City of Edgewater CUSTOMER RECEIPT Oper: EDGEAJ*** Date: 7/29/15 Ol Type: OC Drawer: 1 Receipt no: 87716 Description Quantity 9U OTHER RECORDING FEES Amount 29825 84731.00 TYLER, ROBIN $413.00 3219 YULE TREE OR EDGEWATER, FL 32141 UT UTILITY PAYMENT RReemaining balance: $6421.55 INTEREST EARNINGS $29.43 9M UTILITYIRECORDING F00 EES 1.00 $100.00 8402-01-14-1490 3219 YULE TREE OR WILLIAM J. GARDNER, PA Tender detail CK CHECK 16102 Total tendered $8020.07 Total payment $8020.07 $8020.07 Trans date: 7/29/15 Time: 12:44:50 *** THANK YOU FOR YOUR PAYMENT *** WWW.CITYOFEDGEWATER.ORG CODE ENFORCEMENT/LOT CLEARING LIENS/UTILITY 3219 YULE TREE DRIVE / 8402-01-14-1490 flats of rarnrriinn hnnWnana It (�itntinn It A/P _ r.itntinn 4 QP_nar rinv fins Intara0 rarnrriinn faa 11/12/2009 6416/2026CE 1307 $75.00 $550.00 $0.00 $37.00 $662.00 11/12/2009 6416/2029CE 1307 $75.00 $550.00 $0.00 $37.00 $662.00 12/9/2009 6425/2492LC 1307 $315.00 $0.00 $108.15 $20.00 $443.15 7/27/2010 6498/2766CE 1427 _ $75.00 $0.00 $0.00 $37.00 $112.00 7/27/2010 6498/2722CE 1427 $75.00 $350.00 $0.00 $37.00 $462.00 9/3/2010 6512/205OLC 1427 $482.50 $0.00 $144.11 $20.00 $646.61 11/29/2010 6539/4342CE 884 $150.00 $0.00 $0.00 $37.00 $187.00 4/29/2011 6587/3294CE 1436 $150.00 $0.00 $0.00 $37.00 $187.00 5/24/2012 6715/1892CE 2068 $150.00 $1,000.00 $0.00 $37.00 $1,187.00 8/14/2012 6746/3568LC 2068 $130.00 $0.00 $23.42 $20.00 $173.42 10/1/2013 6915/373CE 3403 $150.00 $1,000.00 $0.00 $37.00 $1,187.00 11/15/2013 6929/4822LC 3403 $85.00 $0.00 $8.83 $20.00 $113.83 4/23/2014 6981/984CE 3481 _ $150.00 $300.00 $0.00 $37.00 $48T00 7/25/2014 7013/4625LC 3481 $75.00 $0.00 $4.64 $20.00 $99.64 9/30/2014 7037/1991LC 3403 $714.09 $0.00 $36.18 $20.00 $770.27 10/14/2014 7042/3799NA $75.00 $0.00 $3.63 $20.00 $98.63 $2,926.59 $3,750.00 $328.96 $473.00 $f,4/8.bb Volusia County Property Appraiser's Office Page 1 of 3 IJolusia Court ' The Volusia County Property Appraiser makes every effort to produce the most accurate information possible. No warranties, expressed or implied, are provided for the data herein, its use or interpretation. The values shown in the Total Values section at the end of the Property Record Card are "Working Tax Roll" values, as our valuations proceed during the year. These Working Values are subject to change until the Notice of Proposed Taxes (TRIM) are mailed in mid -August. For Official Tax Roll Values, see the History of Values section within the property record card below. Last Updated: 7-29- 5 Today's Date: 7-29-201015 Volusia County Property Appraiser's Office Property Record Card (PRC) Morgan B. Gilreath Jr., M.A., A.S.A., C.F.A. volusia County FLORIDA Property Appraiser Full Parcel ID Short Parcel ID 02-18-34-01-14-1490 8402-01-14-1490 Mill Group 604 Edgewater Alternate Key 3958896 - 2014 Final Millage Rate 24.77590 Parcel Status Active Parcel PC Code 01 Date Created 06 JAN 1982 Owner Name BANK OF NEW YORK MELLON TR GO TO ADD'L OWNERS Owner Name/Address 1 Owner Address 2 % 8742 LUCENT BLVD 3RD FLOOR Owner Address 3 HIGHLANDS RANCH CO Owner Zip Code 80129 Owner Percentage 100 Ownership Type Trust Location Address 3219 YULE TREE DR EDGEWATER 32141 LEGAL DESCRIPTION GO TOADD'L LEGAL LOTS 14149 & 14150 BLK 456 FLA SHRS NO 24 REV MB 19 PG 244 P ER OR 4677 PGS 1656-1657 PER OR 5625 PG 0756 PER D/C 6797 PG SALES HISTORY GO TOADD'LSALES # BOOK PAGE DATE INSTRUMENT QUALIFICATION IMPROVED? SALE PRICE 1 7094 4314 3/2015 Certificate of Title Government acquisition Yes 100 2 6797 0149 5/2010 Death Certificate Unqualified Sale Yes 100 3 4677 1656 3/2001 Warranty Deed Unqualified Sale Yes 10 HISTORY OF VALUES I GO TO ADD'L HISTORY YEAR LAND BLDG MISC JUST ASD SCH NS ASD EXEMPT TXBL SCH I ADD'L I NS (S) ASD I TXBL EX TXBL 2014 1 9,600 162,799 1 1,155 1 73,554 1 73,554 1 73,554 172,075 10 1 73,554 1 73,554 10 172,075 http://webserver.vcgov.org/cgi-bin/mainSrch3.cgi 7/29/2015 Additional Legal Information Page 1 of 1 LEGAL DESCRIPTION LOTS 14149 & 14150 BLK 456 FLA SHRS NO 24 REV MB 19 PG 244 P ER OR 4677 PGS 1656-1657 PER OR 5625 PG 0756 PER D/C 6797 PG 0149 PER OR 7094 PG 4314 http://webserver.vcgov.org/cgi-binllglpopup.cgi?Alt_Key=3958896&Roll—Year=0&mode=l 7/29/2015 Robin Matusick From: Robin Matusick Sent: Wednesday, July 29, 2015 6:50 AM To: 'aea12@dbksmn.com' Subject: RE: 3219 Yule Tree Drive - Robin A. Tyler Amber, Did not hear back from you so just wanted to make sure you did not have additional questions/issues. Hope you have a great day! Robin L. Matusick, Paralegal City of Edgewater PO Box 100 Edgewater, FL 32132 (386)424-2400 Ext #1203 From: Robin Matusick Sent: Tuesday, July 21, 2015 11:34 AM To: 'aea12@dbksmn.com' Cc: Kelly Woodworth Subject: FW: 3219 Yule Tree Drive - Robin A. Tyler Importance: High Amber, Hopefully this will satisfy your concerns relating to your letter to the City Attorney dated July 20, 2015. Attached please find the "Updated " Lien Research & Payoff Worksheet that reflects what we discussed — 1) The Code, Lot & Nuisance Abatement liens have been removed/reduced in the amount of $7, 478.55 2) The recording fees for those have been added in the amount of $473.00 Which now brings the total payoff to $8, 020.07. At the time, this is closed/paid off, Satisfactions will be done on the Utility Liens with Releases done on the Code, Lot & Nuisance Abatement Lien. Please let me know if you have any other questions. Robin L. Matusick, Paralegal City of Edgewater PO Box 100 Edgewater, FL 32132 (386)424-2400 Ext 41203 From: Kelly Woodworth Sent: Tuesday, July 21, 2015 11:26 AM To: Robin Matusick Subject: RE: 3219 Yule Tree Drive - Robin A. Tyler Here you go. Kelly From: Robin Matusick Sent: Tuesday, July 21, 2015 11:00 AM To: Kelly Woodworth Subject: RE: 3219 Yule Tree Drive - Robin A. Tyler Importance: High Kelly, Just spoke to Attorney Amber Ashton regarding the above -referenced matter. Can you please send me a Modified Lien Research & Payoff Worksheet to reflect just the utility liens, interest & recording fees. Also, in the payoff please add in the recording fees for the code, lot & nuisance liens in the amount of $473.00. My figures were 9 code liens @ 37 = $333.00 6 lots liens @ 20 = 120.00 I nuisance @10 = 20.00 $473.00 Robin L. Matusick, Paralegal City of Edgewater PO Box 100 Edgewater, FL 32132 (386)424-2400 Ext #1203 From: Kelly Woodworth Sent: Tuesday, July 21, 2015 9:47 AM To: Robin Matusick Subject: RE: 3219 Yule Tree Drive - Robin A. Tyler Just did it yesterday. Here you go. Kelly From: Robin Matusick Sent: Tuesday, July 21, 2015 7:05 AM To: Kelly Woodworth Subject: 3219 Yule Tree Drive - Robin A. Tyler Importance: High Kelly, Have you done a lien assessment worksheet on the above -referenced property for payoff? If so, can you please forward everything to me as an attorney is arguing the matter. This is another foreclosure so has issues. Thanks! Robin L. Matusick, Paralegal City of Edgewater PO Box 100 Edgewater, FL 32132 (386)424-2400 Ext 41203 To signup for Edgewater's E-newsletters click http://www.cityofedgewater.org/how-do-i/receive-email- notifications To Like us on Facebook click https://www.facebook.com/pages/City-of-Edgewater- Florida/156640071072841 To visit our website click http://www.citVofedgewater.org/ Robin Matusick From: Robin Matusick Sent: Tuesday, July 21, 2015 7:05 AM To: Kelly Woodworth Subject: 3219 Yule Tree Drive - Robin A. Tyler Importance: High Kelly, Have you done a lien assessment worksheet on the above -referenced property for payoff? If so, can you please forward everything to me as an attorney is arguing the matter. This is another foreclosure so has issues. Thanks! Robin L. Matusick, Paralegal City of Edgewater PO Box 100 Edgewater, FL 32132 (386)424-2400 Ext #1203 DE BEAUBIEN KNIGHT SIMMONS MANTZARIS & NEAL LLP ♦'r/BI► �' MN ATTORNEYS AND COUNSELLORS AT LAW ORLANDO I TALLAHASSEE I TAMPA W W W.DBKSMN.COM VIA U.S. MAIL DELIVERY AND FACSIMILE DELIVERY Aaron R. Wolfe, Esq. City Attorney - City of Edgewater 104 North Riverside Drive Edgewater, FL 32132 Fax: (386) - 424 - 2421 RE: Code Enforcement Case No.: Property: Our File No. Dear Mr. Wolfe: Reply to Tampa July 20, 2015 2009-CE-8040 (A) & (B); 2010-CE-5023 (A) & (B); 2010-CE-9135; 2011-CE-104036; 12-00105748; 13-00107859; 14-00108404; 14-00108914 3219 Yule Tree Drive Edgewater, FL 49920 Please be advised that Specialized Asset Management, LLC ("SAM"), as the authorized agent of The Bank of New York Mellon F/K/A The Bank of New York, as Trustee for the certificateholders of CWABS, Inc., ASSET -BACKED CERTIFICATES, SERIES 2007-9 (the "Owner"), the current owner of the above referenced property (the "Property"), has retained the undersigned and the law firm of de Beaubien, Knight, Simmons, Mantzaris & Neal, LLP, to represent it in regard to the above referenced matter. Please direct any and all future communications in regard to this matter to me in our firm's Tampa office. This letter is being provided to you in an attempt to resolve a dispute between SAM, the Owner and the City of Edgewater. This letter, and the information set forth herein, is confidential and shall not be admissible in any proceeding without the express consent of our client. Further, 332 NORTh MAqN01iA AVENUE, ORIANdO, F10RidA 32801 725 EAST PARk AVENUE, TAIIAhASSEE, FIORidA 32301 609 WEST HORATIO STREET, TAMPA, FIORidA 33606 MAiN:407-422.2454 1 FAx:407-849.1845 MAiN:850.201.3655 I FAx:850.205.3717 WN:813.251.5825 1 FAx:813.254,1063 Aaron R. Wolfe, Esq. July 20, 2015 Page 2 of 3 the demand and calculations set forth herein shall not be construed as a waiver of any rights, claims, or interests of our client. On the contrary any and all rights, claims and interests are expressly reserved and preserved, whether at law or in equity. Recently, SAM received notice that the City of Edgewater (the "City") has recorded multiple Claims of Lien (hereinafter collectively referred to as the "Liens") against the Property for a code violation(s), which the City claims entitles it to collect over Two Hundred Forty Two Thousand Thirty Seven and 151100 Dollars ($242,037.15) from the Owner. These fines and Liens are for violations which were either barred by the Lis Pendens dated November 29, 2012, or foreclosed as a result of the Final Judgment on February 6, 2015. As such, the Owner disputes the validity of the City's entitlement to these fines. Our research indicates that there were multiple Liens recorded on the subject property: Case No. Date recorded O.R. Book/Page Violation 2009-CE-8040 (B) November 12, 2009 6416/2026 Neglected Premises 2009-CE-8040 (A) November 12, 2009 6416/2029 Property Maintenance 2009-CE-8040 (A) & 2009-CE-8040 (B) December 9, 2009 6425/2492 Lot Clearing March 17, 2010 6455/3732 Utilities 2010-CE-5023 (B) July 27, 2010 6498/2766 City Right of Ways 2010-CE-5023 (A) July 27, 2010 6498/2772 Property Maintenance 2010-CE-5023 (A) September 3, 2010 6512/2050 Lot Clearing 2010-CE-9135 November 29, 2010 6539/4342 Property Maintenance February 17, 2011 6565/3616 Utilities 2011-CE-104036 Aril 29, 2011 6587/3294 Property Maintenance October 21, 2011 6643/3687 Utilities 12-00105748 May 24, 2012 6715/1892 Property Maintenance 12-00105748 August 14, 2012 6746/3568 Lot Clearing August 29, 2012 3753/136 Utilities 13-00107859 October 4, 2013 6915/373 Property Maintenance 13-00107859 November 15, 2013 6929/4822 Lot Clearing 14-00108404 April 23, 2014 6981/984 Property Maintenance 14-00108404 July 25, 2014 7013/4625 Lot Clearing 13-00107859 September 30, 2014 7037/1991 Lot Clearing 14-00108914 April 23, 2014 7042/3799 Property Maintenance Nuisance & Abatement A true and correct copy of the aforementioned Liens are enclosed for your reference. At the time the Liens were recorded, the Property was already the subject of a pending mortgage foreclosure action brought by the Owner. In connection with that action, and pursuant to § 1 To the extent the liens for utility services are not subject to foreclosure, the Owner requests that the City provide a current pay-off of the amounts due for utilities. Aaron R. Wolfe, Esq. July 20, 2015 Page 3 of 3 48.23, Florida Statutes, a Notice of Lis Pendens was recorded in O.R. Book 6788, Page 2070, of the Official Records of Volusia County, Florida, on November 29, 2012. A true and correct copy of the Notice of Lis Pendens is enclosed for your reference. The recording of the Notice of Lis Pendens operated to protect the Owner's interest in the Property from any impairment from intervening liens, including the City's code enforcement liens. See Medical Facilities Development Inc. v. Little Arch Creek Properties Inc., 675 So. 2d 915 (Fla. 1996); Chiusolo v. Kennedy, 614 So. 2d 491 (Fla. 1993). The recording of the Notice of Lis Pendens constituted a bar to the enforcement against the Property of the code enforcement lien/fines referenced above. §48.23(1)(d), Fla. Stat. (2009). Further, once the Property was sold at the judicial sale and the Certificate of Title was issued to the Owner on March 18, 2015, the Property was forever discharged from the alleged liens/fines. Op. Att'y Gen. Fla. 93-77 (1993) (The lis pendens "statute specifically provides that if the proceedings are prosecuted to a judicial sale of the property described in the lis pendens notice, the property is forever discharged from all such unrecorded interests and liens."). True and correct copies of the Certificate of Title and Final Judgment in the Owner's foreclosure are also enclosed for your reference. Even if the City's lien ordinance is deemed to be a "super -priority" ordinance, it would constitute an unconstitutional impairment of the Owner's contractual relations as applied to the mortgage with the former owner, which established the Owner's mortgage lien as a first -priority lien against the Property. Sarasota County v. Andrews, 573 So. 2d. 113 (Fla. 2d DCA 1991); City of Palm Bay v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A., 57 So.3d 226, 227 (Fla. 5th DCA 2011); aff'd, 114 So.3d 924 (Fla. 2013) (holding a City ordinance granting code enforcement liens priority over mortgages conflicts with § 695.11, Florida Statutes, which codifies the common law recording rule of "first in time, first in right," and thus violates Art. VIII, §2(b), Fla. Const., which prohibits such a conflict between municipal ordinances and state statutes). Additionally, the City was a party to the Owner's foreclosure action. As such, any interest that the City may have had in the Property was foreclosed when the Final Judgment was entered. As such, the Owner hereby demands that the City provide Releases of Lien for the aforementioned Liens as soon as possible. The Property is under contract and is expected to close as soon as the Liens can be resolved. To that end, the Owner is willing to pay Five Hundred and 00/100 Dollars ($500.00) towards the City's administrative expenses in order to resolve this matter. Please call me to discuss this matter further. Sincerely yours, ca_(��� Amber Ashton Enclosures 1 IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 7TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR VOLUSIA COUNTY, FLORIDA CIVIL DIVISION The Bank of New York Mellon FKA The Bank of New York, as 'Trustee for the certificateholders ofthe CWABS, Inc., ASSET BACKED CERTIFICATES, SERIES 2007-9 Plaintiff THE ESTATE OF ROBIN A. TYLER a/k/a ROBIN TYLER and all unknown parties claiming by, through, under and against the above named Defendant who are unknown to be dead or alive whether said unknown are persons, heirs, devisees, grantees, or other claimants; UNKNOWN SPOUSE OF ROBIN A. TYLER a/k/a ROBIN TYLER; JODY WHEELER; FLORIDA SHORES PROPERTY OWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC.; CITY OFEDGEWATER, FLORIDA; TENANT UUNKNOWN TENANT; TENANT II/UNKNOWN TENANT; TENANT III/UNKNOWN TENANT and TENANT IV/UNKNowN TENANT, in possession of the. subject real property, Defendants 02/06/2015 11:07 AN Instrtll^entf 2015-020941 I 1 Book: 7080 Page: 3E57 Case No. 2012-20921 CINS lvOz) FINAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT OF FORECLOSURE u+ 0 a� -n rri - �... r' rrr�r�trn rn;= i>� 1r9 o iae�' r THIS MATTER came before this Honorable Court upon Plaintiffs Motion for Final Summary Judgment of Foreclosure, and Attorney Fees and Costs, wherein the Court finds that service ofprocess was properly rendered against Defendants. All Defendants were properly served with process and were then either voluntarily dismissed or timely defaulted. The Court also finds that all Defendants have failed to assert any material facts or issues that precludes summaryjudgment. The Court finds that Plaintiff has filed Affidavits and Exhibits herein as proof of the sums due; and the Court having heard argument of counsel and being fully and sufficiently advised in the premises, IT IS ORDERED AND ADJUDGED: 1. The Court has j urisd iction over the Defendants, TIM ESTATE OF ROBIN A. TYLER Okla ROBIN TYLER; JODY WHEELER; FLORIDA SHORES PROPERTY OWNERS Insti-ment# 2015-020°41 # 2 Book: 7080 Page: 3688 ASSOCIATION,INC.; CITY OFEDGEWATER, FLORIDA, who were served with process and properly and either answered or were timely defaulted, along with subject matter jurisdiction over this cause and all party Defendants. 2. The Court finds the original mortgage and promissory note have been accepted into evidence, with the promissory note being canceled. 3. The Court finds that Court finds that ROBIN A. TYLER a/k/a ROBIN TYLIM, died on May 18, 2013 and did not have a probate estate established in the interest of ROBINA. TYLER a/k/a ROBIN TYLER in Volusia County, Florida, nor has a Last Will and Testament for ROBIN A. TYLER a/k/a ROBIN TYLER been located. The Court in order to protect the interest of the Estate appointed a Guardian/Attomey Ad Litem, Richard Filson, an Attorney in good standing with the Florida Bar, who has filed an answer and his report is accepted into evidence by this judgment. The Court finds that publication has'occurred and that the requirements of due process and notice have been met in this matter. 4. Plaintiff is owed as follows: A. Principal $138,508.65 B. Interest from 10/1/08 through 10/31/14, with a per $71,606.86 diem thereafter of $32.2554 C. Additional Interest to the date of this Judgment $3,032.01 D. Title Search $0.00 E. Foreclosure Report $325.00 F. Close Out Search 0. Escrow Advanced $15,422.82 Insurance $0.00 Taxes $0.00 H. Late Charges $161.46 1. Filing Fees $1,007.50 J. Publication Fee $80.00 K. Service of Process $495.00 L. Appraisal Fee $0.00 M. Recording Fees $10.00 N. Property Inspection $921.85 O. Property Preservation $6,666.00 P Attorney Fee $3,800.00 TOTAL $242,037.15 The sum of $242.037.15 , shall bear interest until paid in full at the lawful promulgated rate Instrument# 2015-020941 # 3 Book: 7080 Page: 3659 •1 of four point seventy-five percent (4.751/o) starting in 2015 and shall then be determined by in accordance with Florida Statue 55.03 by the State of Florida for each successive quarter thereafter until paid in full. 5. The Court finds that the 21.71 hours expended by counsel for Plaintiff in obtaining this Final Summary Judgment is a reasonable number of hours, and that the range ofhourly rates charged by the attorney working on this matter for Plaintiff of One Hundred Seventy Five Dollars [$175.00] is reasonable and is the prevailing rate charged in this Judicial Circuit by lawyers of reasonable comparable skill, experience, and reputation for similar lawyers. Accordingly, the Court finds that the amount of One Hundred Seventy Five Dollars [$175.00] per hour for a period of 21.71 hours for a total attorney's fee of Three Thousand Eight Hundred Dollars ($3,800.00) as set forth herein the above paragraph is reasonable. 6. Plaintiff, The Bank of New York Mellon FICA The Bank ofNew York, as Trustee for the certificateholders of the CWABS, Inc., ASSET -BACKED CERTIFICATES, SERIES 2007-9, whose address is c% 8742 Lucent Blvd., 3rd Floor, Highlands Ranch, CO 80129, holds a lien on the subject real property for the total sum of this judgment which is superior in dignity, right, title and interest to all persons, firms, estates, corporations claimed by Defendants THE ESTATE OF ROBIN A. TYLER a/k/a ROBIN TYLER; JODY WHEELER; FLORIDA SHORES PROPERTYOWNERS ASSOCIA.TION,INC.; CITYOFEDGEWATE R,FLORID.Aand other in possession of the subject real property and any other joined Defendants or all other persons and legal entities taking subject to notice by Plaintiffs Lis Pendens as to the real property with a legal description as follows: LOT 14149 AND 14150 IN BLOCK 456, FLORIDA SHORES #24 REVISED, ACCORDING TO THE PLAT THEREOF, AS RECORDED IN MAP BOOK 19 AT PAGE 244 OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF VOLUSIA COUNTY, FLORIDA. Address: 3219 Yule Tree Dr., Edgewater, FL 32141. 7. If the total sum with interest at the rate described in Paragraph 3 and all costs accrued subsequent to this judgment are not paid fr om the date ofthis judgment, the Clerk of the Court shall sell the property at Public Sale on the _ day of �� , 2015 at 11:00 A.M: to 10, Instrmmentf 2015-020941 4 . Book: 7060 Page: 3660, the highest bidder for cash, except as prescribed in the above paragraph to be held at www.Volusia.Realforeclose cQm in accordance with Section 45.031, Florida Statutes. The Clerk of Court shall not conduct the sale unless Plaintiff or its representative is present to bid at the sale. S. Plaintiff may assign the judgment and credit bid by the filing of an Notice of Assignment Bid without further order of this Court. 9. Plaintiff shall advance all subsequent costs of this action. Should a party other than Plaintiff be the purchaser at the sale, Plaintiff shall be reimbursed by the Clerk for costs advanced including the Clerk's fee to conduct the sale and publication cost. Provided however that. the purchase of the property for sale shall be responsible for the documentary stamps payable on the. certificate of title. At the time ofpayment of the bid amount any purchaser other than Plaintiff shall pay a service charge assessed by the Clerk of the Circuit Court pursuant to Florida Statute 28.24, together with documentary stamps to be affixed to the Certificate of Title. If Plaintiff Is. the purchaser, the Clerk shall credit Plaintiffs bid with the total sum with interest and.costs accruing subsequent to this judgment, or such part of it, as is necessary to pay the bid in full. Plaintiff may, if subsequent to the date of Plaintiffs Affidavit in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment, ,file . an amended affidavit for additional sums owed as contemplated by this judgment. Any sums Plaintiffis required to advance any monies to protect its mortgage lien, then Plaintiffshall so certify to the Clerk of Court and the amount found due to Plaintiff shall be increased by the amount of such an advance with further order of the Court. 10. On filing the Certificate of Title, the Clerk shall distribute the proceeds of the sale, so far as they are sufficient, by paying: A. All of Plaintiffs costs; B. Plaintiffs attorney fees; C. Total sum due to Plaintiff, less the items paid, and the same shall bear interest at the lawful promulgated rate until paid in full. D. The balance of the proceeds of the sale in excess of the amounts paid under Paragraphs 9(a) (b) & (c) shall be retained by the Clerk of this Court pending further order of this Court. 11.On filing the Certificate of Sale the right ofredemption shall be terminated and upon the Instrument# 9 5 Book: 7080 Pager 3661 ie Certificate of Title, Defendant and all persons claiming under or against them since the filing of the Notice of Lis Pendens shall be foreclosed of all estate. or claim in the property and the purchaser at the sale shall be let into possession of the property located at 3219 Yule Tree Dr., Edgewater, FL 32141. If any defendant remains in possession of the property, the Clerk forthwith a writ of possession upon the request of the person named on the certificate of title. The Sheriff is hereby authorized to serve the Writ of Possession thereafter and place Plaintiff Into physical possession of the subject property. 12. IF THIS PROPERTY IS SOLD AT PUBIC AUCTION, THERE MAY BE ADDITIONAL MONEY FROM THE SALE AFTER PAYMENT OF PERSON WHO ARE ENTITLED TO BE PAID FROM THE SALE PROCEEDS PURSUANT TO THE FINAL JUDGMENT IF YOU ARE A SUBORDINATE LIEN HOLDER CLAIMING A RIGHT TO FUNDS REMAINING AFTER THE SALE, YOU MUST FILE A CLAIM WITH THE CLERK NO LATER THEN 60 DAYS AATER THE SALE. IF YOU FAIL, TO FILE A CLAIM, YOU WILL NOT BE ENTITLED TO ANY REMAINING FUNDS. IF YOU ARE THE PROPERTY OWNER, YOU MAY CLAIM THESE FUNDS YOURSELF. YOU ARE NOT REQUIRED TO HAVE A LAWYER OR ANY OTHER REPRESENTATIVE AND YOU DO NOT HAVE TO ASSIGN YOUR RIGHTS TO ANYONE ELSE IN ORDER FOR YOU TO CLAIM ANY MONEY TO WHICH YOU ARE ENTITLED. PLEASE CHECK WITH THE CLERK OF THE COURT, VOLUSIA COUNTY, WITHIN 10 DAYS AFTER THE SALE TO SEE IF THERE IS ADDITIONAL MONEY FROM THE FORECLOSURE $ALE THAT THE CLERK HAS IN THE REGISTRY OF THE COURT. IF YOU DECIDE TO SELL YOUR HOME OR HIRE, SOMEONE TO HELP YOU CLAIM THE ADDITIONAL MONEY, YOU SHOULD READ VERY CAREFULLY ALL PAPERS YOU ARE REQUIRED TO SIGN, ASK SOMEONE ELSE, PREFERABLY AN ATTORNEY WHO IS NOT RELATED TO THE PERSON OFFERING TO HELP YOU, TO MAKE SURE THAT YOU UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU ARE SIGNING AND THAT YOU ARE NOT 'TRANSFERRING YOUR PROPERTY OR THE EQUITY IN YOUR PROPERTY WITHOUT THE PROPER INFORMATION. IF YOU CANNOT AFFORD TO PAY AN ATTORNEY, YOU MAY CONTACT THE COMMUNITY LEGAL SERVICES OF MID-FLORIDA, INC., (386) 255-6573, To SEE IF YOU QUALIFY FINANCIALLY FOR THEIR SERVICES. IF THEY CANNOT ASSIST YOU, THEY MAY BE ABLE TO REFER YOU TO A LOCAL BAR REFERRAL AGENCY OR SUGGEST OTHER OPTIONS. IF YOU CHOOSE TO CONTACT LEGAL AID FOR ASSISTANCE YOU SHOULD DO SO AS SOON AS POSSIBLE AFTER RECEIPT OF THIS NOTICE. C� Plaintiff` otio or Instanter Amendment to is nd Complai i ude code lien ded Nast R. B k 6715 Pa 189 th ubIic Rec s of sia Co ty, Flori nted said lien is eluded in the a ed comp ' t a ' set forth the . verbatim. 14. Jurisdiction is retained to enter further Orders that are proper against Defendants including a deficiency judgments if the borrower has not been discharged in bankruptcy, writs of possession. relief as set forth in Florida Statute 702.07, relief which would include a supplemental complaint, re -foreclosure, post judgment proceedings and all otherrelief deemed necessary.and just. DONE AND ORDERED in Chambers, Volusia County, Florida, this day of 2015. 0 CIRC IT OURT JUDGE Conformed Copies To The Estate of Robin A. Tyler a/k/a Robin Tyler Florida Shores POA, Inc. c/o Richard Filson, Ad Litem c/o Joann Cowell, as R.A. 2727 S Tamiami Trl Ste 2 3045 Vista Palm Drive Sarasota, Florida 34239-4523 Edgewater, Florida 32141 filsonlawfirm@gmall.com City of Edgewater, Florida 104 N Riverside Dr Edgewater FL 32132 Gary I. Gassel, Esquire 2191 Ringling Boulevard Sarasota, Florida 34237 Jody Wheeler . 1512 Regina CT. Mount Sterling, KY 40353 Instrument# # 6 Bock: 7080 Page: 3662 Diane H. Hatousek Volusia County, Clerk of Court 08/29/2012 03:40 PM Instrument# 2012-156510 # 1 THIS INSTRUMENT PREPARED BY Book : 6753 AND SHOULD BE RETURNED TO: Page : 1 36 Robin Matusick,Paralegal Diane N. Matousek CITY OF EDGEWATER Volusia County, Clerk of Court 104 North Riverside Drive Edgewater,FL 32132-0100 (386)424-2400,Option#1&Ext#1203 UTILITIES LIEN CITY OF EDGEWATER ROBIN A. TYLER Pursuant to the provisions of Chapter 19 (Section 19-6), Code of Ordinances, City of Edgewater, Florida, the City of Edgewater (the "City") furnished utilities services to the following described real property located in Volusia County, Florida: Lots 14149 & 14150, Block 456, Florida Shores #24, Rev MB 19, PG 244 per OR 4677, PGS 1656-1657 per OR 5625, PG 0756 in the public records of Volusia County, Florida (Property location: 3219 Yule Tree Drive, Edgewater, FL), Parcel #8402-01-14-1490. The record owner is ROBIN A. TYLER, 3219 Yule Tree Drive, Edgewater, FL 32141. The City hereby claims a lien in the amount of EIGHT HUNDRED THIRTY-FOUR and 81/100 dollars ($834.81), plus interest in the amount of seven percent (7%) per annum from the date the utility bill was rendered, filing fees, and any other costs incurred by the City. WITNESSE CITY OF EDGEWATER,FLORIDA ien Tra •y T.Barlow Ci• Manager riXADU Y�l� i5 1�— Dated: t G � Signed,sealed and delivered in the presence of: STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF VOLUSIA I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this day, before me, an officer duly authorized in the State and County aforesaid to take acknowledgments,personally appeared TRACEY T. BARLOW, CITY MANAGER for the City of Edgewater, who is duly authorized to execute this document on behalf of the City of Edgewater, Florida, and is personally known to me and who executed the foregoing instrument and acknowledged before me that he executed the same. WITNESS my hand and official seal in the County and State last aforementioned this 27th day of August, 2012. (Seal/Stamp) cC�V‘'a ®` (Commission Expiration Date) Notary Public �+` p�VS�CK••/ �/i;d State of Florida at Large o .'s'oN EXP/gFS': ' Z , 2013 0.41; . \v �� �"' ' •• O oa��c� . ` Liens/UtilityLien-Tyler-3219YuleTree-August-2012 ���� • �•••iosP•'S,V rilRY PUB\ AO' Volusia County Property Appraiser's Office Page 1 of 3 Volusia County Appraisers Office i' kt The Volusia County Property Appraiser makes every effort to produce the most accurate information possible. No warranties, expressed or implied, are provided for the data herein, its use or interpretation. The values shown in the Total Values section at the end of the Property Record Card are "Working Tax Roll" values, as our valuations proceed during the year. These Working Values are subject to change until the Notice of Proposed Taxes (TRIM) are mailed in mid-August. For Official Tax Roll Values, see the History of Values section within the property record card below. Volusia County Property Appraiser's Office Last Updated: 06-26-2012 Property Record Card (PRC) Today's Date: 6-29-2012 Morcian B. Gilreath Jr., M.A.,A.S.A., C.F.A. Volusia County FLORIDA. Property Appraiser Full Parcel ID 02-18-34-01-14-1490 Mill Group 604 Edgewater Short Parcel ID 8402-01-14-1490 Alternate Key 3958896 2011 Final Millage Rate 25.34070 Parcel Status Active Parcel PC Code 01 Date Created 06 JAN 1982 Owner Name ROBIN A TYLER ( GO TO ADD'L OWNERS ) Owner Name/Address 1 Owner Address 2 3219 YULE TREE DR Owner Address 3 EDGEWATER FL Owner Zip Code 321416433 Location Address 3219 YULE TREE DR EDGEWATER 32141 LEGAL DESCRIPTION LOTS 14149 & 14150 BLK 456 FLA SHRS NO 24 REV MB 19 PG 244 P ER OR 4677 PGS 1656-1657 PER OR 5625 PG 0756 SALES HISTORY ( GOTOADD'LSALES # BOOK PAGE DATE INSTRUMENT QUALIFICATION IMPROVED? SALE PRICE 1 4677 1656 3/2001 Warranty Deed Unqualified Sale Yes 10 2 4149 2438 10/1996 Quit Claim Deed Unqualified Sale Yes 10 3 3216 1108 10/1988 Warranty Deed Qualified Sale Yes 51,400 HISTORY OF VALUES ( GO TO ADD'L HISTORY ) YEAR LAND BLDG MISC JUST ASD SCH NS ASD EXEMPT TXBL SCH ADD'L NS (S) ASD TXBL EX TXBL 2011 11,600 45,803 5,048 62,451 62,451 62,451 62,451 0 62,451 62,451 0 62,451 2010 16,800 52,946 5,428 75,174 75,174 75,174 75,174 0 75,174 75,174 0 75,174 LAND DATA CODE TYPE OF FRONTAGE DEPTH #OF UNIT RATE DPH LOC SHP PHY JUST LAND USE UNITS TYPE VAL IMP PVD http://webserver.vcgov.org/cgi-bin/mainSrch3.cgi 6/29/2012 s Jun 29, 2012 8:45:24 AM EDT L-1J File Edit Commands Help A ccount 298 + 4 Customer Information Customer Alerts receIu Accounts recelvahlr ,f3 = .,-) ®Consumption Customer name; TYLER, ROBIN Confidential: No ® VVA ABATER Billing address; 3219 YULE TREE DR Cash only; to Cieuit history data y Cs E-r�ctif cotton: Active ®Deposits EDCENATER, FL 32141-54.3^ IDB account Pendlnytransartioj Delivery point: Special. code: Phone number 0 Budget billing: No ®Recent activity g 9 I , r Special notes. Yes i 1 .. 4 Print Customer Account Information �'r Service Summary ✓3 0 Current balance: 3,208.46 Service address: 3219 YULE TREE DR EDar^NAT Cancel Deferred amount: 0.00 Y Initiation date: 10/31/1.989 Amount due: 3,259,46 I Account status: ACTPVE ve OK Pending: 0.00 f ._us toner type: 171. Delinquent amount: 3,204.42 Service Rate Group Status Neter Exit Last notice: _____ __ _=__ -__�_ Cutoff date: 7110,12 --- --- - �- + 11 it Next customer -.._,_,__..__ ., ..._...__. _....... _._.. Select custo� .__.r -"--.,._.._� -. Trn Tv,e Tv ie Trn Date I osr npiwn Bill Date Due Date Amount Runtime Balance Next location / ... 213 Ad 6/220/12 20 Day Delq 5/28/12 30 2.770 3,158 42 RF l y day delinquent Selectlocation EC Bill 6/25/12 E CYC SILL 6/28/12 ± 18/12 54.04 , 3,228.46 _ l 74.42 CusrlocI'uncti... ;ES Acli 6/04/12 j30 day delinquent. 30.00 3,171.72 13F' Ado 6/02/12 30 day delinquent 4/28/12 30.U0 3,201.72 Consumption... RF Adh 6/01/12 30 day delinquent ' 4/28/12 30.00 3,171.72 20 Adl 5/23/12 20 Day Delg Charge 4/28/12 --- 2.70 3,141.72 k Service eiders EC .Bill 5/22/12 E CYC BILL 5/28/12 6/18/12 54.04 3,139.02 Custer rnet ma RF Ado 5/01/12 30 day delinquent 3`FEIVAIN1VIPtaseraet-P4015) "°':' -' EC .Bill 4/25/12 E CYC BILL 4t „.., 20 ado 4/19/12 20 Day Lelq Charge , Prot essinq trda Emotmcation 2 2 1 from tray 3 RF Adz 3/31/12 20 day delinquent 2 • Miscellaneou... EC '.Bill 3/21/12 ECYC BILL 3 } Adi 3/20/12 20 Day Delq Charge 2 E ' Jump setup PF Ad3 3/02/12 30 day delinquent 1 ,. ''i il. I :_ Oo .l.