07-20-1993
.......
..."
Edgewater Firefighters' Pension Fund
Minutes
Regular Meeting
Tuesday, July 20, 1993
Conference Room, City Hall
6:42 P.M.
The Regular Meeting of the Firefighters' Pension Fund was
called to Order by Chairman Al Gilbert on Tuesday, July
20, 1993 at 6:32 p.m. in the Conference Room of City Hall.
ROLL CALL: Members present were:
Cas tetter , Chief William C. Vola, Mr.
Ben Wagner, and Chairman Al Gilbert.
Recording Secretary Lisa R. Warren.
Firefighter James
Robert Morin, Mr.
Also present was
APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES: The Minutes for the April 20,
1993 Regular Meeting were submitted for approval. Mr.
Wagner moved to accept the Minutes as submitted. Mr. Morin
seconded. Motion CARRIED 5-0.
CHAIRMAN'S REPORT: Chairman Gilbert informed the Board
the Insurance Department had deposited $19,000 in the
account for a share of Chapter 175. He added the June 30th
statement stated the cash account now held approximately
$28,000 and it should be invested soon.
Chairman Gilbert gave a report from the seminar in St.
Petersburg. He informed the Board the check for the
registration fee was sent to FPPTA was credited to our
membership fees and the Board was billed for the
registration fee. Chief Vola asked if there had been any
discussion on Health Insurance subsidy rewriting Chapter
175. Chairman Gilbert stated they mentioned it and you can
request to get into it, but it will cost. Chief Vola
stated if the membership of the pension wanted it, the
Board could propose it, but it would have to be adopted by
Ordinance. He added he would like to see the information
passed on to the membership in a less complicated form so
that it would be easily understandable. There was
discussion regarding the benefits of having a health plan.
Chairman Gilbert stated he did not get an answer from the
State regarding the 5 year versus 10 year vestment. He did
get a letter from the State defining disability benefits
which states: "The Edgewater Firefighters' Pension Plan is
a Chapter Plan under Florida Statute 175 and provides line
of duty disability from the date of hire. There is a 10
year service requirement for any other than line of duty
disability." He stated they also sent a short synopsis of
everything Chapter 175 does for each member. He added a
copy of this should go to the membership.
NEW BUSINESS: Chairman Gilbert asked if there was any new
business at this time. There was none at this time.
UNFINISHED BUSINESS: Chairman Gilbert stated he checked
into Sugarman's bill and the Board owes him the $135.00 in
question from the last bill. He added that Ernst and
Young, the City's CPA's, requested information from the
attorney if there were any outstanding lawsuits against
the Board. Mr. Sugarman furnished them with an official
answer so the audit could be completed showing there were
no outstanding liabilities. Mr. wagner moved to pay the
bill. Mr. Morin seconded. There was discussion regarding
the bill being too expensive. Motion CARRIED 4-1. Chief
Vola voted NO.
1
........ ...,
Edgewater Firefighters' Pension Fund
Regular Meeting
Tuesday, July 20, 1993
Page 2
Chairman Gilbert submitted his
seminar in St. petersburg which
20, 1993 meeting. The total
$341.39.
expense voucher for the
was approved at the April
amount for expenses was
Chief Vola stated at the last meeting he was directed to
talk to Mr. Munoz, the City's Finance Director, regarding
the City picking up the tab to do our Annual Report and
the Audit. He added Mr. Munoz said yes to both of them.
Chief Vola stated the City would do the Audit since they
have to do it anyway and they will issue us a report at no
charge. He added the City will fill out the Annual Report
since they have to verify it anyway, the Board will have
to approve it and the Chairman and Secretary will have to
sign it. Chief Vola feels that the Board shouldn't have to
pay for a CPA when the auditors are going to check it as
well as the State and the Board. Chairman Gilbert asked if
there would be a charge coming from the City. Chief Vola
stated there would be no hidden charges, the City is
already doing the same thing for the Police Department and
the General Employees Pension Fund and it's just another
piece of paper. Chairman Gilbert stated for the time being
it would save us money, but for the future the Board
should be aware that they have the authority to run the
pension fund and as it gets larger the Board should look
in the direction of hiring a CPA. There was discussion as
to what procedures to follow.
Chairman Gilbert asked again if the Board still wanted him
to pursue looking at the 5 year vestment as opposed to the
10 year vestment. Chief Vola stated he had received a
letter from the membership that they had informally
decided to let it be for the time being. Chief Vola asked
that Chairman Gilbert find out the costs of doing an
actuarial study so they would know the cost up front
before considering any changes to the benefits of the
present plan.
Chairman Gilbert requested a five minute recess at 7: 02
p.m. Meeting resumed at 7:08 p.m.
Chairman Gilbert passed around a handout from the seminar
regarding possible changes to the Chapter 175 & 185 that
would remove the limitation on public pension trust
investments in overseas corporations. Chairman Gilbert
said it doesn't pertain to us at this time because of the
amount of money there is in the fund. He added that down
the line they could be advised that the Board could make
more money in an overseas investment. There was discussion
regarding investments.
Chairman Gilbert informed the Board that he had received a
letter from the City stating that William Finch is no
longer employed by the City of Edgewater as of June 30th.
There was discussion regarding the proper procedure for
requesting funds from the Pension Fund.
Firefighter Hayes asked where the Pension Board was
heading and what it was considering for the membership.
Chief Vola stated the Board members can raise issues with
the membership but it is the responsibility of the members
of the Pension to come to the Board with suggestions. It
is the Board's responsibility to give the membership
feedback as to how viable the idea would be to implement.
Chairman Gilbert stated he should post a copy of the
"Duties and Responsibilities of Trustees" put out in 1991
so they could understand what the duties of Board.
2
'-' ...,
Edgewater Firefighters' Pension Fund
Regular Meeting
Tuesday, July 20, 1993
Page 3
Chief Vola stated there is a process of checks and
balances. The City Council must agree to any changes and
so must the Board before any changes can be implemented;
each checks the other.
ADJOURNMENT: There being no more business to come before
the Board at this time, Mr. Wagner moved to adjourn.
Firefighter Cas tetter seconded. Meeting adjourned at 7:32
p.m.
If any person decides to appeal any decision made by the pension
Board of Trustees with respect to any matter considered at the above
meeting, that person will need a record of the proceedings and, for
such purpose, may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the
proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and
evidence upon which the appeal is to be based.
3